PlasmidEC and gplas2: An optimised short-read approach to predict and reconstruct antibiotic resistance plasmids in Escherichia coli

Abstract

Accurate reconstruction of Escherichia coli antibiotic resistance gene (ARG) plasmids from Illumina sequencing data has proven to be a challenge with current bioinformatic tools. In this work, we present an improved method to reconstruct E. coli plasmids using short reads. We developed plasmidEC, an ensemble classifier that identifies plasmid-derived contigs by combining the output of three different binary classification tools. We showed that plasmidEC is especially suited to classify contigs derived from ARG plasmids with a high recall of 0.941. Additionally, we optimised gplas, a graph-based tool that bins plasmid-predicted contigs into distinct plasmid predictions. Gplas2 is more effective at recovering plasmids with large sequencing coverage variations and can be combined with the output of any binary classifier. The combination of plasmidEC with gplas2 showed a high completeness (median=0.818) and F1-score (median=0.812) when reconstructing ARG plasmids and exceeded the binning capacity of the reference-based method MOB-suite. In the absence of long read data, our method offers an excellent alternative to reconstruct ARG plasmids in E. coli. Data SummaryNo new sequencing data have been generated in this study. All genomes used in this research are publicly available at the GenBank and Sequence Read Archive of the National Center for Biotechnology Information. Accession numbers are specified in Supplementary Materials. Scripts to reproduce the results reported in this manuscript can be accessed at https://gitlab.com/jpaganini/ecoli-binary-classifier. The ensemble classifier, plasmidEC, is publicly available at https://gitlab.com/mmb-umcu/plasmidEC (release 1.3.1), and gplas2 (release 1.0.0) can be found at https://gitlab.com/mmb-umcu/gplas2. Impact StatementEscherichia coli has emerged as a highly pervasive multidrug resistant pathogen on a global scale. The dissemination of resistance is significantly influenced by plasmids, mobile genetic elements that facilitate the transfer of antimicrobial resistance genes within and between diverse bacterial species. Consequently, precise and high-throughput identification of plasmids is imperative for effective genomic surveillance of resistance. However, accurate plasmid reconstruction remains challenging with the use of affordable short-read sequencing data. In this work, we present a novel method to accurately predict and reconstruct E. coli plasmids based on Illumina data. Additionally, we demonstrate that our approach outperforms the reference-based method MOB-suite, especially when reconstructing plasmids carrying antimicrobial resistance genes.