Stepping-stone population structure and sidespread clonality of the mesophotic octocoral Swiftia exserta in the warm temperate northwest Atlantic

Abstract

Isolated mesophotic banks form spatially discrete networks of patchy ecosystems along continental shelves. Their long-term persistence depends on connectivity among populations of the dominant coral species that structure these communities. Yet the scale of larval-mediated gene flow across these networks remains poorly characterized. Similarly, the extent to which clonal propagation shapes local population dynamics is unresolved, leaving the relative contributions of sexual and asexual reproduction to population maintenance an open question. Here, population genomics and high-resolution (1km) biophysical larval dispersal modeling are integrated to resolve the genetic connectivity and clonal dynamics of Swiftia exserta, a key habitat-forming octocoral, across 13 mesophotic banks spanning the U.S. Gulf and eastern coast within the Warm Temperate Northwest Atlantic (WTNWA) coastal and shelf biogeographic province. Genome-wide SNP markers derived from Restriction-site Associated Sequencing (RADseq) were genotyped across 288 individuals. About 40% of individuals belonged to clonal genets confined to single banks within meters of one another, indicating that asexual propagation sustains local density but plays no detectable role in inter-bank connectivity. Population genetic analyses pointed to isolation by distance as the primary structuring force, with the majority of molecular variance residing within rather than among populations. The west-most population, East Flower Garden Banks, was the most differentiated population in the WTNWA Northern Gulf ecoregion, reflecting its peripheral position within the bank network. The Edisto population from the WTNWA Carolinian ecoregion, was distinct from all others, implicating the Florida Peninsula as a phylogeographic barrier. Biophysical particle-tracking simulations independently recovered the same spatial structure, with modeled larval exchange consistent with the genomic signal across the bank network. These findings reveal that S. exserta persists across the northern WTNWA province through a dual reproductive strategy of clonality at the bank scale and episodic larval exchange at the network scale, with implications for the conservation and management of mesophotic octocoral metacommunities.