The Gordian Knot Enhances Ubiquitin Binding in UCH-L1

Abstract

UCH-L1 is a monomeric deubiquitinating enzyme whose native structure embeds a shallow $5_2$ knot located near the N-terminus, placing the knotted topology in direct proximity to both the substrate-binding pocket and the catalytic site. While our previous work established that N-terminal integrity is critical for catalytic activity, the energetic cost of unknotting and its structural consequences remained unquantified. Here, we combine steered molecular dynamics with an umbrella sampling scheme to generate topologically modified variants of UCH-L1 and, for the first time, reconstruct the free-energy profile of UCH-L1 unknotting. The potential of mean force reveals a steep energetic barrier to knot disruption, consistent with knotting being a late, rate-limiting folding step that is effectively locked in once the native structure is established. Long unbiased MD simulations of fully unknotted variants in both apo and holo states show that knot removal increases local flexibility at the N-terminus without inducing significant global structural destabilization. Binding energy calculations indicate that the unknotted variant binds to ubiquitin less tightly than the wild-type ($\sim$-62~vs~$\sim$-76~kcal/mol), suggesting that topological integrity contributes to substrate affinity. Together, these results show that the $5_2$ knot in UCH-L1 is not a passive structural feature but a functional element that fine-tunes folding kinetics and contributes to substrate binding efficiency.