Genotypic context modulates fitness landscapes: Effects onthe speed and direction of evolution for antimicrobialresistance

Abstract

Understanding the forces that drive the dynamics of adaptive evolution is a goal of many subfields within evolutionary biology. The fitness landscape analogy has served as a useful abstraction for addressing these topics across many systems, and recent treatments have revealed how different environments can frame the particulars of adaptive evolution by changing the topography of fitness landscapes. In this study, we examine how the larger, ambient genotypic context in which the fitness landscape being modeled is embedded affects fitness landscape topography and subsequent evolution. Using simulations on empirical fitness landscapes, we discover that genotypic context, defined by genetic variability in regions outside of the locus under study (in this case, an essential bacterial enzyme target of antibiotics), influences the speed and direction of evolution in several surprising ways. These findings have implications for how we study the evolution of drug resistance in nature, and for presumptions about how biological evolution might be expected to occur in genetically-modified organisms. More generally, the findings speak to theory surrounding how \"difference can beget difference\" in adaptive evolution: that small genetic differences between organisms can greatly alter the specifics of how evolution occurs, which can rapidly drive even slightly diverged populations further apart.\n\nAuthor summaryTechnological advances enable scientists to engineer individual mutations at specific sites within an organisms genome with increasing ease. These breakthroughs have provided scientists with tools to study how different engineered mutations affect the function of a given gene or protein, yielding useful insight into genotype-phenotype mapping and evolution. In this study, we use engineered strains of bacteria to show how the dynamics (speed and direction) of evolution of drug resistance in an enzyme depends on the species-type of that bacterial enzyme, and on the presence/absence of mutations in other genes in the bacterial genome. These findings have broad implications for public health, genetic engineering, and theories of speciation. In the context of public health and biomedicine, our results suggest that future efforts in managing antimicrobial resistance must consider genetic makeup of different pathogen populations before predicting how resistance will occur, rather than assuming that the same resistance pathways will appear in different pathogen populations. With regard to broader theory in evolutionary biology, our results show how even small genetic differences between organisms can alter how future evolution occurs, potentially causing closely-related populations to quickly diverge.