Sociality and nesting strategy shape the bimodal diversity gradient in bees

Abstract

Bees are dominant pollinators across native and agricultural plant communities, yet the drivers of their patterns of geographic distribution and functional diversity remain poorly understood. Notably, bees exhibit a bimodal latitudinal diversity gradient, peaking in species diversity in temperate and arid regions rather than the tropics despite their close ecological and evolutionary ties to flowering plants, which show the opposite pattern. Here, we investigated whether two key life history traits thought to shape where bees can live--sociality and nesting strategy--may influence this pattern. We compiled data on sociality and nesting strategy for 4,293 bee species and combined it with a comprehensive phylogeny, curated global occurrence records, and newly-developed models of trait evolution to test 1) whether sociality and nesting biology are evolutionarily correlated, 2) how these life history traits shape bees climatic niches and niche breadths, and 3) whether the evolutionary dynamics of these traits may explain the bimodal latitudinal gradient in bee diversity. We find that the evolution of above-ground nesting is closely tied to the evolution of social behavior, but this trait combination has evolved rarely across the evolutionary history of bees. Where this combination does arise, species that are both social and above-ground nesters tend to have narrower climatic niches and are associated with environments that are warmer, wetter, and experience little seasonal temperature variation, making them more prevalent in tropical bee communities. Together, our results indicate that the bimodal diversity gradient in bees is driven by phylogenetic niche conservatism, where most bee lineages retain ancestral traits suited to arid environments and the derived syndrome necessary for thriving in the tropics evolves rarely.