Substantial intraspecific variation in energy budgets: biology or artefact?

Abstract

O_LIDynamic energy budget (DEB) models provide a mechanistic description of life-histories in terms of fluxes of energy through biological processes. In these models, life-histories are a function of environmental conditions and of fundamental traits of the organism relating to the acquisition, allocation, and use of energy. C_LIO_LIThese traits are described by the parameters of the DEB model, which have been estimated for over 2500 species. Recent work has aimed to compare species on the basis of differences in DEB parameters. C_LIO_LIWe show that caution is required in such analyses, because (i) parameter estimates vary considerably as an artefact of the types of data used to fit the models, and (ii) there is substantial intraspecific variation in parameter values, reflecting biological differences among populations. C_LIO_LIWe show that similar patterns of growth and reproduction can be reproduced with very different parameter sets. Our results imply that direct comparison of DEB parameters across populations or species may be invalid. However, valid comparisons are possible if differences in the types of data used to fit the models are taken into account. C_LIO_LIWe estimated DEB parameters for 16 populations of Trinidadian guppy, identifying differences in resource allocation and metabolic rate consistent with evolved life-history differences among these populations. C_LIO_LIVariation in parameter values was substantial: if intraspecific variation in DEB parameters is greater than currently measured levels of interspecific variation, the detection of broad-scale patterns in energy budgets across species will be challenging. C_LI