Biology subjects

Avery-Gomm, S.

Publications and source records attributed to Avery-Gomm, S..

9 recordsLinked to original sources

bioRxiv2024

Strategies for Mitigating Impacts to Aerofauna from Offshore Wind Energy Development: Available Evidence and Data Gaps

A diversity of approaches exist for mitigating (e.g., avoiding, minimizing, or compensating for) the effects of offshore wind energy (OSW) development on birds and bats, but little is known about the effectiveness of many of these approaches. To address this knowledge gap, we reviewed the scientific and gray literature to evaluate the evidence base for potential bird- and bat-related mitigation approaches for OSW, including studies from other industries where relevant (e.g., terrestrial wind energy, offshore oil and gas industry). Of a total of 219 mitigation approaches, most focused on minimization, with far fewer addressing avoidance or compensation. Sixty-five percent had no evidence of testing. Of the 76 mitigation approaches that were field tested or implemented, we found evidence of effectiveness for only 40 approaches, of which only 10 were specific to the OSW sector. Consequently, a majority of all the mitigation approaches for birds (82%) and bats (89%) lacked any evidence of effectiveness. For birds, minimization approaches related to lighting reduction were the most tested and effective methods for reducing maladaptive attraction and collisions. For bats, minimization approaches involving adjustments to turbine operations (e.g., curtailment of turbine blades) were most tested and effective methods for reducing collisions. Given the limited evidence of effectiveness for most mitigation approaches, assuming their success systematically underestimating project-level and cumulative impacts, underscoring the need to prioritize avoidance, consistent with the mitigation hierarchy, and rigorously test mitigation approaches for birds and bats in offshore environments. RESUMEIl existe une diversite dapproches pour attenuer (e.g. eviter, minimiser ou compenser) les effets du developpement de l lEnergie Eolienne Extracotiere (EEE) sur les oiseaux et les chauves-souris, mais lefficacite de nombreuses de ces approches est encore peu connue. Pour combler ces lacunes, nous avons passe en revue la litterature scientifique et la litterature grise afin devaluer les donnees probantes concernant les mesures dattenuation potentielle pour lEEE et les oiseaux et les chauves-souris,, inclus des etudes dautres industries lorsque cela etait pertinent (e.g., lenergie eolienne terrestre, lindustrie petroliere et gaziere extracotiere). Sur un total de 219 approches dattenuation pertinentes pour lEEE, la plupart des approches se concentraient sur la minimisation, avec beaucoup moins dapproches portant sur levitement ou la compensation. Soixante-et-un pourcent des approches proposees ne semblent pas avoir ete testees. Parmi les 76 approches dattenuation qui ont ete testees sur le terrain ou mises en uvre, nous avons trouve des preuves de leur efficacite pour seulement 40 approches, dont seulement 10 etaient specifiques ale secteur de lEEE. Par consequent, la majorite des approches dattenuation pour les oiseaux (82 %) et les chauves-souris (89%) ne disposaient daucune preuve defficacite. Chez les oiseaux, les approches de minimisation liees a la reduction de leclairage etaient les methodes les plus couramment testees et les plus efficaces pour reduire lattraction et les collisions. Chez les chauves-souris, les approches de minimisation impliquant la modification du fonctionnement des turbines (e.g., reduction de la vitesse de rotation ou mise en drapeau des helices) etaient les methodes les plus couramment testees et les plus efficaces pour reduire les collisions. Compte tenu des preuves limitees de lefficacite de la plupart des approches dattenuation, le fait de presumer de leur succes conduit a une sous-estimation systematique des impacts a lechelle des projets et des impacts cumulatifs, ce qui souligne la necessite de privilegier levitement, conformement a la hierarchie dattenuation, et de tester rigoureusement les mesures dattenuation pour les oiseaux et les chauves-souris en milieux offshore. IMPLICATIONS FOR MANAGERSO_LIBased on our literature review of potential mitigation approaches for birds and bats in relation to offshore wind development, most approaches remain untested or lack evidence of effectiveness (bats - 89%, birds - 82%). C_LIO_LIMost minimization approaches have primarily been tested in the terrestrial context, leaving important questions regarding the transferability of these results to the offshore environment. C_LIO_LIGiven the limited evidence of effectiveness for most mitigation approaches, assuming their success systematically underestimates project-level and cumulative impacts, underscoring the need to prioritize avoidance and rigorously test mitigation approaches for birds and bats in offshore environments. C_LI

ecology↗

bioRxiv2024

A Flexible Framework for Assessing the Cumulative Effects of Offshore Wind Energy Activities and Other Pressures on Aerofauna

The offshore wind energy (OSW) industry is pivotal for renewable energy transition and climate resiliency. However, OSW activities may negatively affect aerofauna, contributing to CE from human activities and natural processes. Cumulative effects assessments (CEA) are vital for informed planning and management of OSW activities during regional assessment, site selection, and site evaluation. To reduce impacts on aerofauna, OSW developments should be sited in areas that avoid or minimize cumulative effects (CE). This study presents a cohesive and flexible framework for assessing the CE from OSW activities, other human activities, and natural processes on aerofauna to support decision-making during the initial OSW planning phases. The framework uses a species-based approach, applicable to various receptors, and adapts to available information on ecology, socioeconomics, and pressures. The analytical strategy uses a CE metric to indicate the presence or magnitude of effects from all pressures on receptors. Spatially explicit optimization methods identify OSW site configurations that minimize a CE metric. The framework accommodates alternative pressure scenarios that include foreseeable future human activities and natural processes and can explore the sensitivity of the result to uncertain parameters. Given sufficient spatial information on receptor density, pressure magnitude, and cause-effect pathways, the spatial optimization algorithm can find solutions that minimize population-level impacts from CE. If this ideal standard cannot be achieved due to information gaps, alternative metrics may be used to inform the immediate decision-making process.

ecology↗

bioRxiv2024

Seabird and sea duck mortalities were lower during the second breeding season in eastern Canada following the introduction of Highly Pathogenic Avian Influenza A H5Nx viruses

H5N1 clade 2.3.4.4b viruses have caused significant mortality events in various wild bird species across Europe, North America, South America, and Africa. In North America, the largest impacts on wild birds have been in eastern Canada, where over 40,391 wild birds were reported to have died from highly pathogenic avian influenza (HPAI) between April and September 2022. In the year following, we applied previously established methods to quantify total reported mortality in eastern Canada for a full year October 2022, to September 2023. In this study, we (i) document the spatial, temporal and taxonomic patterns of wild bird mortality in the 12 months that followed the mass mortality event in the summer of 2022 and (ii) quantify the observed differences in mortality across the breeding season (April to September) of 2022 and 2023. In eastern Canada, there was high uncertainty about whether 2023 would bring another year of devastating HPAI-linked mortalities. Mortalities in the breeding season were 93% lower in 2023 compared to 2022 but encompassed a more taxonomically diverse array of species. We found that mortalities in the fall and winter (non-breeding season) were dominated by waterfowl, while mortalities during the spring and summer (breeding season) were dominated by seabirds. Due to a low prevalence of HPAI among the subset of tested birds, we refrained from broadly attributing reported mortalities in 2023 to HPAI. However, our analysis did identify three notable mortality events linked to HPAI, involving at least 1,646 Greater Snow Geese, 232 Canada Geese, and 212 Northern Gannets. This study emphasizes the ongoing need for H5NX surveillance and mortality assessments as the patterns of mortality in wild populations continue to change.

ecology↗

bioRxiv2024

Strengths and limitations of using participatory science data to characterize a wildlife mass mortality event

Large participatory science (i.e., "community science" or "citizen science") platforms are increasingly used at every level of ecological and conservation research, including disease monitoring. Here, we used a comprehensive, ground-truthed mortality dataset to judge how well participatory science data from iNaturalist represented the magnitude, taxonomic, temporal, and spatial patterns of waterbird mortality associated with a mass mortality event following the incursion of Highly Pathogenic Avian Influenza in eastern Canada in 2022. The iNaturalist dataset was effective at identifying species with high mortality (especially Northern Gannets, Morus bassanus), along with the time period and spatial regions with high concentrations of avian deaths. However, iNaturalist data severely underestimated the magnitude, overestimated the taxonomic breadth, and poorly represented the full geographic scope of disease-related deaths. Our results suggest iNaturalist can be used to identify the species, timing, and location of relatively high mortality in situations where no other information is available, and to supplement conventional sources of data. However, iNaturalist alone can neither quantify the magnitude nor pinpoint the mechanisms of mortality and therefore is not a viable substitute for comprehensive mortality assessments.

ecology↗

bioRxiv2024

Geographic, ecological, and temporal patterns of seabird mortality during the 2022 HPAI H5N1 outbreak on the island of Newfoundland

Highly pathogenic avian influenza (HPAI) H5N1 caused mass seabird mortality across the North Atlantic in 2022. Following outbreaks in Europe, the first case in North America was detected on the island of Newfoundland (NFLD), Canada in November 2021, before spreading through all North American flyways. During the following breeding season, NFLD experienced the second-highest number of seabird mortalities in Canadian provinces. Surveys and citizen reports identified 13543 seabird mortalities from April to September 2022. Many carcasses occurred on the west coast of NFLD in May and June 2022. Reported mortalities peaked in July along the southeastern coast. In August and September, mortalities were concentrated along the northeastern coast. With the exception of two colony surveys, reported mortalities decreased in September. Most mortality was found among Northern Gannet (6622), Common Murre (5992), Atlantic Puffin (282), and Black-legged Kittiwake (217). Using comprehensive knowledge of seabird ecology, we formulated exploratory hypotheses regarding traits that could contribute to mortality. Species differences in mortality were most strongly associated with nesting density, timing of breeding, and at-sea overlap with allospecifics from other colonies. Unprecedented seabird mortality and ongoing transmission within the circulating avian influenza viruses highlight the need for continued monitoring and development of conservation strategies.

zoology↗

bioRxiv2024

Wild bird mass mortalities in eastern Canada associated with the Highly Pathogenic Avian Influenza A(H5N1) virus, 2022

In 2022, a severe outbreak of clade 2.3.4.4b Highly Pathogenic Avian Influenza (HPAI) H5N1 virus resulted in unprecedented mortality among wild birds in eastern Canada. Tens of thousands of birds were reported sick or dead, prompting a comprehensive assessment of mortality spanning the breeding season between April 1 and September 30, 2022. Mortality reports were collated from federal, Indigenous, provincial, and municipal agencies, the Canadian Wildlife Health Cooperative, non-governmental organizations, universities, and citizen science platforms. A scenario analysis was conducted to refine mortality estimates, accounting for potential double counts from multiple sources under a range of spatial and temporal overlap. Correcting for double counting, an estimated 40,966 wild birds were reported sick or dead in eastern Canada during the spring and summer of 2022. Seabirds and sea ducks, long-lived species that are slow to recover from perturbations, accounted for 98.7% of reported mortalities. Mortalities were greatest among Northern Gannets (Morus bassanus; 26,193), Common Murres (Uria aalge; 8,133), and American Common Eiders (Somateria mollissima dresseri; 1,945), however, these figures underestimate total mortality as they exclude unreported deaths on land and at sea. In addition to presenting mortality estimates, we compare mortalities with known population sizes and trends and make an initial assessment of whether population-level impacts are possible for the Northern Gannet, a species that has suffered significant global mortality, and two harvested species, Common Murre and American Common Eider, to support management decisions. We hypothesize that population-level impacts in eastern Canada are possible for Northern Gannets and American Common Eiders but are unlikely for Common Murres. This study underscores the urgent need for further research to understand the broader ecological ramifications of the HPAI outbreak on wild bird populations.

zoology↗

bioRxiv2023

Avian influenza viruses in wild birds in Canada following incursion of the highly pathogenic H5N1 virus from Eurasia in 2021/2022

Following detection of novel highly pathogenic avian influenza virus (HPAIV) H5N1 clade 2.3.4.4b in Newfoundland, Canada in late 2021, avian influenza surveillance in wild birds was scaled-up across Canada. Herein, we present results of Canadas Interagency Surveillance Program for Avian Influenza in wild birds during the first year (November 2021 - November 2022) following the incursions of HPAIV from Eurasia. Key objectives of the surveillance program were to (i) detect the presence, distribution and spread of HPAIV and other avian influenza viruses (AIVs), (ii) detect wild bird morbidity and mortality associated with HPAIV, (iii) identify the range of wild bird species infected by HPAIV, and (iv) characterize detected AIV. A total of 6,246 sick and dead wild birds were tested, of which 27.4% were HPAIV positive across 12 taxonomic orders and 80 species. Geographically, HPAIV detections occurred in all Canadian provinces and territories, with the highest numbers in the Atlantic and Central flyways. Temporally, peak detections differed across flyways, though the national peak occurred in April 2022. In an additional 11,295 asymptomatic harvested or live captured wild birds, 5.2% were HPAIV positive across 3 taxonomic orders and 19 species. Whole genome sequencing identified HPAIV of Eurasian origin as most prevalent in the Atlantic flyway, along with multiple reassortants of mixed Eurasian and North American origins distributed across Canada, with moderate structuring at the flyway scale. Wild birds were victims and reservoirs of HPAIV H5N1 2.3.4.4b, underscoring the importance of surveillance encompassing samples from sick and dead, as well as live and harvested birds to provide insights into the dynamics and potential impacts of the HPAIV H5N1 outbreak. This dramatic shift in presence and distribution of HPAIV in wild birds in Canada highlights a need for sustained investment in wild bird surveillance and collaboration across One Health partners.

zoology↗

bioRxiv2023

High pathogenicity avian influenza (H5N1) in Northern Gannets: Global spread, clinical signs, and demographic consequences

During 2021-22 High Pathogenicity Avian Influenza (HPAI) killed thousands of wild birds across Europe and North America, suggesting a change in infection dynamics and a shift to new hosts, including seabirds. Northern Gannets (Morus bassanus) appeared especially severely impacted, but limited understanding of how the virus spread across the metapopulation, or the demographic consequences of mass mortality limit our understanding of its severity. Accordingly, we collate information on HPAIV outbreaks across most North Atlantic gannet colonies and for the largest colony (Bass Rock, UK), provide impacts on population size, breeding success, adult survival, and preliminary results on serology. Unusually high numbers of dead gannets were first noted in Iceland during April 2022. Outbreaks in May occurred in many Scottish colonies, followed by colonies in Canada, Germany and Norway. By the end of June, outbreaks had occurred in five Canadian colonies and in the Channel Islands. Outbreaks in 12 UK and Ireland colonies appeared to follow a clockwise pattern with the last infected colonies recorded in late August/September. Unusually high mortality was recorded at 40 colonies (75% of global total colonies). Dead birds testing positive for HPAIV H5N1 were associated with 58% of these colonies. At Bass Rock, the number of occupied sites decreased by at least 71%, breeding success declined by [~]66% compared to the long-term UK mean and adult survival between 2021 and 2022 was 42% lower than the preceding 10-year average. Serological investigation detected antibodies specific to H5 in apparently healthy birds indicating that some gannets recover from HPAIV infection. Further, most of these recovered birds had black irises, suggestive of a phenotypic indicator of previous infection. Untangling the impacts of HPAIV infection from other key pressures faced by seabirds is key to establishing effective conservation strategies for threatened seabird populations, HPAIV being a novel and pandemic threat.

ecology↗

bioRxiv2022

Existing caribou habitat and demographic models are poorly suited for Ring of Fire impact assessment: A roadmap for improving the usefulness, transparency, and availability of models for conservation

Decision making in conservation science often relies on the best available information. This may include using models that were not designed for purpose and are not accompanied by an assessment of limitations. To begin addressing these issues, we sought to reproduce, and evaluate the suitability of, the best available models for predicting impacts of proposed mining on boreal woodland caribou (Rangifer tarandus caribou) resource selection and demography in northern Ontario. We then evaluated their suitability for projecting the impacts of development in the Ring of Fire region. To aid in accessibility, we developed an R package for data preparation, analyses of resource selection, and demographic parameters. We found existing models were either ill suited, or lacking, for ongoing regional planning. The specificity of the regional resource selection model limited its usefulness for predicting impacts of development, and the high variability across caribou ranges limited the usefulness of a national aspatial demographic model for predicting range-specific impacts. Variability in model coefficients across caribou ranges suggests selection responses vary with habitat availability (i.e. a functional response) while demographic responses continue to decline with increasing disturbance. Models designed for forecasting that are continuously updated by range-specific demographic and habitat information, are required to better inform conservation decisions and ongoing policy and planning practices in the Ring of Fire region.

ecology↗