Compass orientation of a migratory mammal in total darkness

Abstract

Many animals use the Earth's magnetic field to orient and navigate over long distances, yet the sensory mechanism that underlies this ability remains unresolved. A central question is whether the compass depends on light: a cryptochrome-based radical-pair mechanism, best characterised in birds, requires a photon to generate the magnetically sensitive species, whereas magnetic particle-based and inductive mechanisms do not. In mammals, which lack the light-sensitive cryptochromes that the avian model requires, this question is unresolved. Here we tested whether migratory bats, Pipistrellus nathusii, require light for migratory orientation, studying wild migrants at a major flyway under laboratory-controlled light conditions, including verified total darkness. Bats were acclimated to starlight-level illumination or to total darkness before release into a circular arena in which take-off direction was recorded, and take-off latency was taken in every trial as a control for behavioural state. Bats released under starlight-level illumination, and bats released in total darkness after starlight acclimation, both oriented in the south-westerly direction typical of free-flying bats at this flyway; their mean headings lay 11 degrees apart and did not differ in direction, in angular concentration, or in take-off latency. Bats released in total darkness after prolonged darkness produced the same mean heading but did not reach significance under a Rayleigh test, and did not differ from either other group. To our knowledge, this is the first demonstration that a migratory mammal expresses its seasonally appropriate migratory heading in total darkness. Bats orienting in darkness took off five to eight minutes after their last photon exposure, seven to eight orders of magnitude beyond the microsecond lifetime of the only cryptochrome radical pair demonstrated to exist and to be magnetically sensitive. Because a compass reading is informative only at the moment of the directional decision, a signal generated before a bat entered darkness could not encode its heading at take-off; the magnetically sensitive species must therefore form without photons. The radical pairs capable of doing so have not been shown to exist, even in vitro. A migratory mammal thus expresses its seasonal heading without concurrent light, in a lineage lacking the photoreceptor on which the light-dependent compass in birds relies.