bioRxiv Science⌕ Search

bioRxiv · 10.64898/2026.09.23.753733

Time-calibrated phylogenomics reveals relationships and parallel evolution of neoteny within Elateriformia (Coleoptera) despite pervasive homoplasy

Abstract

The controversy over Elateriformia relationships hampers understanding of the evolution of disparate soft-bodied and fully sclerotized phenotypes, bioluminescence, and the ontogenetic reprogramming that leads to larviform females. Elateriformia contains >50,000 species in 34 families, including fireflies, jewel, and click beetles. We sample 31 families and 195 ingroup taxa, each with up to 4,224 orthologs. Through explicit hypothesis testing, coalescent-based approaches, and evaluation of dataset properties, we resolve backbone relationships. We reconfirm the monophyly of Byrrhoidea sensu lato, rejecting the recent resurrection of Dryopoidea, and verify the reciprocally monophyletic lampyroid and elaterid clades. We characterize short internodes and gene-tree discordance, both of which are indicative of ancient rapid radiations. Counterintuitively, signals from moderately variable genes are crucial for resolving certain splits, suggesting that even subtle rate differences distinguish phylogenetically informative loci from overly conserved, less informative markers. Time-calibrated phylogenies indicate the early origin of Elateriformia (281-287 Mya), with superfamilies diverging at the Permian-Triassic boundary and diversifying throughout the Jurassic. We identify 15 independent origins of soft-bodiedness and neotenic modifications spanning the Mid Jurassic to the present. Our hypothesis provides a foundation for investigating the genetic mechanisms underlying ontogenetic reprogramming and bioluminescence.

Explore related subjects

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Kusy, D., Motyka, M., Biffi, G., Arias, E. T., Ciampor, F., Anton, E., Carlton, C. E., Caterino, M. S., Escalona, H. E., Hajek, J., Owens, B., Pentinsaari, M., Slipinski, A., Zwick, A., Bocak, L.. 2026-09-29. Time-calibrated phylogenomics reveals relationships and parallel evolution of neoteny within Elateriformia (Coleoptera) despite pervasive homoplasy. https://doi.org/10.64898/2026.09.23.753733

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related preprints

Reticulate Evolution and Plastome Restructuring Shape Asian Passiflora Diversification

Asian Passifloraceae occupy a distinctive evolutionary and ecological position within the family despite their relatively low species diversity compared with the Neotropics. Many Asian representatives are highly localized, small and often ephemeral climbers that persist seasonally through rhizomes, tuberous stems or dormant seeds, while considerable morphological plasticity may obscure species limits and evolutionary relationships. Xishuangbanna, southwestern China, lies at the convergence of Southeast Asian, Indian-Himalayan and southern Chinese floristic elements and represents an important regional centre of Passifloraceae diversity, with two species of Adenia and five species of Passiflora, including the recently described P. xishuangbannaensis and P. menghaiensis. We investigate the evolutionary relationships, plastome evolution and population genomics of these taxa using complete plastome assemblies, a concatenated dataset of 68 selected plastid protein-coding genes, 356 reconstructed nuclear Coding Sequences (CDS), and Genotyping-By-Sequencing (GBS) across the known wild distribution of P. xishuangbannaensis. Plastid, concatenated nuclear and nuclear coalescent phylogenies were strongly incongruent and differed from published classifications based on morphology and earlier phylogenies (ITS, ncpGS, ctyGS, ndhF and trnL-F). Gene-tree discordance and phylogenetic-network inference indicated widespread incomplete lineage sorting together with introgression. The two statistically best-supported network models placed P. menghaiensis, which showed high genetic similarity to the Indian P. napalensis, as a sister lineage involved in independent reticulation events associated with P. altebilobata, P. xishuangbannaensis and P. sumatrana. A pronounced biogeographic pattern was evident within Passiflora supersection Disemma, particularly in the P. siamica-P. cochinchinensis lineage across the Hua Line, whereas relationships among other Asian Passiflora blurred this boundary. This pattern suggests that diversification and reticulation within the Asian lineage may have overlapped temporally with the development of the biogeographic divide represented by the Hua Line. The concentration of early-diverging lineages around Xishuangbanna and the eastern Himalayan-Indian region further points to this area as an important centre in the early diversification of Asian Passiflora. Within this context, the highly localized P. xishuangbannaensis may represent either a relictual of an early Asian lineage or the surviving product of an ancient reticulate complex, contrasting with lineages such as P. siamica that subsequently expanded farther across Southeast Asia. Comparative plastome analyses revealed extensive structural and gene-content evolution within subgenus Decaloba, including pseudogenization, gene and intron losses, and repeated Inverted-Repeat (IR) expansions and contractions; substantial plastome modification also characterized supersection Disemma. Passiflora sumatrana exhibited a particularly distinctive IR expansion extending into the accD-pafII region, potentially characterizing this lineage. Adenia plastomes were generally more structurally conservative, although A. penangiana displayed an IR-boundary contraction involving the rps19-rpl2 region. Mitochondrial CDS and non-coding regions provided the best-resolved phylogenetic signal and revealed strong discordance with the chloroplast phylogeny, consistent with maternal mitochondrial inheritance and variable plastid transmission, potentially involving paternal or biparental inheritance and heteroplasmy. GBS analyses of P. xishuangbannaensis using complementary distant-reference, de novo and closely related-reference approaches showed that mapping to P. organensis provided the clearest SNP distribution and population resolution. ADMIXTURE, PCA and FST analyses revealed two strongly geographically structured populations with additional substructure and substantial differentiation (FST = 0.112). Linkage disequilibrium based demographic reconstruction using GONE2 indicated declining effective population size (Ne) toward the present in both populations, with a particularly abrupt recent decline in Pop1 and a more gradual decline in Pop2. Few candidate Self-Incompatibility (SI) genes could be confidently reconstructed, including limited recovery of highly variable docking regions. However, the intracellular region of an S-locus Receptor Kinases (SRK) contained a distinctive non-synonymous substitution predicted to alter protein configuration without major disruption of overall folding, potentially contributing to compatibility differences between populations. Together, these results reveal a complex evolutionary history combining historical dispersal, incomplete lineage sorting, reticulation, morphological plasticity, plastome structural evolution and strong population differentiation. The narrow distributions and recent demographic decline of these newly recognized Xishuangbanna taxa emphasize their conservation importance, while broader Asian taxon sampling and deeper genomic sequencing will be essential to resolve the evolutionary history of this discreet and poorly known Passifloraceae radiation.

evolutionary biology↗

Who are my Neighbours? Selection Targets Robustness to Full Replication Events, Not to Individual Mutations

Theory predicts that populations should evolve mutational robustness the ability to maintain a constant phenotype despite mutations. However, selection does not operate on individual mutations but on phenotypes resulting from entire replication events, which may involve a variable number of mutations. We therefore distinguish mutational robustness from replicative robustness, defined as the probability that a replication event produces similarly fit offspring. Mutational and replicative robustness may seem closely aligned at first sight, but we show with an evolutionary simulation model that they can be selected in opposite directions. Our results show that while genomes with high redundancy and/or large amounts of non-coding DNA are mutationally robust, they are replicatively fragile because their size increases the number of mutations per replication. This is especially relevant when genomes are at risk of severe disruption from chromosomal rearrangements. Our results expose limits of the fitness landscape metaphor in the context of robustness evolution: neutral plateaus may be mutationally robust but replicatively unstable and therefore disfavoured by selection, whereas narrow peaks arising from densely encoded genomes can replicate more reliably. Our results identify replicative robustness as a distinct target of selection that depends not only on tolerance to individual mutations but also on their overall likelihood of occurring.

evolutionary biology↗

Rethink the Sink: Urban cores act as leaky sinks to maintain regional gene flow in coyotes

Urbanization is an accelerating evolutionary force, yet the patterns and drivers of urban gene flow remain largely obscured. This leaves a critical gap in testing the interplay between demographic and genetic models of urban connectivity. Specifically: the urban fragmentation model, where structural barriers restrict gene flow and drive genetic drift; the urban facilitation model, where permeable matrices enhance functional connectivity; and the urban sink hypothesis, a demographic model where high mortality creates unsustainable population sinks. We used high-resolution RAD-capture data to conduct landscape genomics and gene flow analyses to resolve these models and investigate contemporary evolution in urban coyotes (Canis latrans) across the greater Los Angeles, CA, USA metropolitan area. By incorporating fine-scale environmental, social-ecological, and historical variables of the built environment, we rigorously assessed how urban heterogeneity shapes intra-city evolutionary dynamics. We found weak population structure, heavily influenced by family groups. There was extensive landscape permeability and gene flow across the study area including across four major highways. We also identified heavily asymmetric gene flow from exurban source populations into the urban core, supporting the urban sink paradigm. However, rather than acting as a genetic dead-end, the urban matrix showed striking functional heterogeneity: one urban core functioned as a 'genetic sponge,' absorbing unique transient alleles from multiple surrounding sources, and both urban cores operated as permeable 'leaky sinks,' exporting critical gene flow to other populations. Consequently, urban demographic sinks can simultaneously act as vital genetic bridges. Our findings reject a pure urban fragmentation model while demonstrating that demographic sink dynamics and genetic facilitation are not mutually exclusive. This demonstrates that high-turnover urban sinks can buffer regional biodiversity against genetic erosion, highlighting the need to prioritize matrix permeability and inter-patch connectivity in urban conservation strategies.

evolutionary biology↗