Mitochondrial DNA copy number in neurodegenerative diseases: a global meta-analysis of 156 comparisons across 76 studies

Abstract

Mitochondria are central hubs for cellular metabolism and mitochondrial dysfunction is a hallmark of many chronic diseases. Consequently, changes in mitochondrial DNA copy number (mtDNA-CN), the number of mtDNA genomes per cell or tissue sample, are associated with diseases ranging from cancer and obesity to psoriasis and all-cause mortality. MtDNA-CN especially holds promise as a biomarker for neurodegenerative diseases, but whether and how mtDNA-CN changes with neurodegeneration is controversial. Here, we performed a systematic review and meta-analysis of 76 studies including 156 comparisons of mtDNA-CN in populations with or without a neurodegenerative disease to identify overall trends and potential moderators that explain variation among studies. Overall, mtDNA-CN was not statistically different with neurodegeneration, but heterogeneity among studies was extreme (I2 = 99.5%). The diagnosed disease explained the most variation. For example, Alzheimer's patients showed a 21% decrease in mtDNA-CN, but there was no change in mtDNA-CN with Parkinson's disease. Decreases in mtDNA-CN during neurodegeneration were also more extreme at older ages. Surprisingly, the tissue sampled for mtDNA-CN was not particularly influential, except for certain diseases. Studies published in earlier years also showed more extreme decreases in mtDNA-CN with neurodegeneration. Excessive heterogeneity persisted even after accounting for all moderators and their interactions (I2 = 85.7%). We conclude that the general perception of decreased mtDNA-CN with neurodegeneration is a vast oversimplification that may stem from legacy effects of early studies. However, mtDNA levels offer great promise as biomarkers for neurodegeneration, other diseases, and general health metrics, assuming appropriate complications can be considered.