Ancestral phototrophic Rhizobiaceae evolved in association with algae, then plants

Abstract

Rhizobiaceae serve as classical models for elucidating mutualistic plant-microbe interactions yet they represent a narrow phylogenetic subgroup of Alphaproteobacteria. Studying additional lineages of Rhizobiaceae, we observed broad associations with oxygenic phototrophs beyond land plants, including early branching clades of submerged plants, multicellular and unicellular algae, as well as cyanobacteria. In particular, bacteria of the genus Hoeflea were often affiliated with cyanobacteria or microbial algae, whereas Peteryoungia spp. colonized roots of submerged plants. While both genera were originally described as nonpigmented heterotrophs, our detailed genomic, biochemical and physiological analyses revealed that most strains actually contained genes for anoxygenic photosynthesis. Under oligotrophic, oxic growth conditions, each characterized representative expressed bacteriochlorophyll a-containing functional photosynthetic complexes. Photosynthesis genes shared the highest homology among phylogenetically closest relatives, displaying topologies congruent to cognate house-keeping gene phylogenies, and maintained highly conserved gene synteny across the chromosomes of different species. Together, this indicated a vertical inheritance and long ancestral history of aerobic anoxygenic photosynthesis in Rhizobiaceae rather than multiple recent horizontal transfers. Subsequent time-scale phylogenetic analysis suggested that the last common ancestor of Rhizobiaceae was an aquatic phototroph, with different lineages of Rhizobiaceae consecutively evolving in association with algae, land plants, then later legumes. While aquatic lineages maintained photosynthetic machinery till today, Rhizobia which developed symbioses with land plants either as mutualistic endosymbiosis within root nodules or as plant pathogens, concomitantly lost photosynthetic capability. Based on our results, multiple biotic interactions with diverse oxygenic phototrophs drove the early evolution of Rhizobiaceae.