Quantitative profiling of intrinsic dCas9-DNA recognition reveals key determinants of guide RNA performance

Abstract

CRISPR technologies based on nuclease-deactivated Cas9 (dCas9) rely on programmable DNA binding rather than DNA cleavage, yet the intrinsic DNA-recognition properties that govern optimal guide RNA (gRNA) performance remain poorly understood. Existing approaches either measure genomic occupancy in cells or infer dCas9 behavior from cleavage-based Cas9 datasets, despite DNA binding being substantially more permissive than DNA cleavage. Here we introduce TANGO (Targeted Array-based Nucleic acid-Guided Occupancy), a high-density DNA-array platform that quantitatively profiles intrinsic dCas9:gRNA binding across tens of thousands of DNA targets in a cell-free system. TANGO captures established features of dCas9 target recognition, while providing substantially greater sensitivity than prior assays. Comparison with ChIP-seq data demonstrates that intrinsic DNA-binding specificity is a major driver of genomic occupancy and reveals that chromatin accessibility modulates the intrinsic binding affinity required for dCas9 recruitment. Across CRISPRi/a guides, TANGO identifies multiple independent biochemical determinants of guide performance--including on-target affinity, mismatch tolerance, and ribonucleoprotein assembly--and flags problematic and highly promiscuous guides overlooked by current specificity metrics. Unexpectedly, some guides retain substantial guide-directed DNA binding even in the absence of a protospacer-adjacent motif (PAM), revealing an additional dimension of dCas9 specificity. Together, these results establish intrinsic DNA recognition as a quantitative and experimentally accessible determinant of dCas9 function, providing a framework for improving guide selection and enhancing the precision of CRISPR technologies.