“Mapping of Gonadal Development in Cryptorchidism: UTF-1 and Germ Cell Dysgenesis”

Abstract

Study questionHow does cryptorchidism affect germ cell development and UTF-1-mediated pluripotency potential at the time of orchiopexy? Summary answerCryptorchidism was associated with the following germ cell abnormalities: germ cell clustering with many cords/tubules lacking germ cells and reduced UTF-1 expression, suggesting limited germ cell differentiation into spermatogonia What is known alreadyCryptorchidism, affecting 1.6-9% of male newborns, is known to increase the risk of infertility and testicular cancer due to abnormal germ cell development. Germ cells and pluripotent stem cell gene, UTF-1, play critical roles in spermatogonia differentiation, self-renewal, and spermatogenesis. No prior study has evaluated the testicular development by immunohistochemically mapping of these cell populations, Study design, size, durationA cross-sectional study of 31 postnatal cryptorchid testis and 5 age-matched scrotal testicular biopsies obtained from UCSFs pathology department performed between 1993-2023. Participants/materials, setting, methodsSpecimens were grouped by age at surgery (6-18 months, 19 months-7 years, 8-12 years, and [≥]13 years) and testis location (palpable vs. non-palpable). Scrotal prepubertal testis biopsies were sourced through the Pedi-LIFE program, a fertility preservation research biobank, with at least one control per age group. Immunohistochemistry was performed to stain specimens for germ cell (DDX4, OCT4, TSPY), pluripotent cell marker (UTF-1), as well as other key testis cell markers (A-actin, AR, P450, Sox-9), with staining graded based on control expression levels. The number of germ cells per seminiferous tubule was quantified and compared across anatomical locations using appropriate statistical analyses. Main results and the role of chanceThis study included 36 specimens, comprising 31 cryptorchid testes (86%) and 5 scrotal control testes (16%). The cryptorchid group exhibited testicular dysgenesis and reduced germ cell expression, correlated with increased age and testis location. Qualitative assessment revealed reduced germ cell expression across all ages in cryptorchid testes. The number of germ cells per tubule was markedly reduced in cryptorchid compared with scrotal testes after 19 months of age for DDX4, TSPY, and UTF-1. Germ cell clusters were identified in 15 out of 31 cryptorchid specimens (48%) stained for DDX4 and TSPY. UTF-1 expression was lower in cryptorchid testes across all age groups. No significant differences were noted in other testicular cell markers. Large scale dataNA Limitations, reasons for cautionFirst, the power and generalizability of the study are limited by the availability of specimens within each age group, particularly for scrotal testes, as biopsies of these tissues are not routinely performed. Second, a cross-sectional study design limits a longitudinal comparison to evaluate changes in marker expression, delayed maturation, or irreversible germ cell loss. Third, immunohistochemistry data is semi-quantitative, and protein detection is affected by antibody sensitivity and tissue preservation and influenced by antibody sensitivity. Lastly, scrotal testis used as controls were obtained from cryopreserved tissue from patients with other unrelated pathology, which may influence histological profiles. Wider implications of the findingsCollectively, our findings support a model in which cryptorchidism involves both germ cell depletion and disrupted SSC lineage formation, with UTF-1 downregulation and germ cell clustering as early signatures of testicular dysgenesis. These features may help identify high-risk patients for worsening gonadal dysgenesis and infertility and can provide a rationale for earlier orchiopexy or SSC-preserving strategies. Study funding/competing interest(s)The authors declare no conflicts of interest and received no funding for this study. Data Availability StatementThe data underlying this article cannot be shared publicly due to ethical and legal restrictions related to the use of human tissue specimens, which may compromise donor privacy and confidentiality. Data are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request and subject to institutional and ethical approvals.