When cold-bloods heat up: meta-analytical evidence that climatic variability mediates behavioural fever in amphibians and reptiles

Abstract

Fever is a widespread and adaptive defence response that enhances immune performance through an increase in body temperature above normal values. In ectotherms, fever is expressed behaviourally through the selection of warmer microhabitats following infection, yet its magnitude and determinants vary widely across species and environments. Here, we performed a phylogenetically informed meta-analysis of behavioural fever in amphibians and reptiles to test whether its expression was shaped by climatic thermal variability, pathogen identity, and taxonomy. Specifically, we tested the hypotheses that (i) species from thermally variable environments would exhibit stronger behavioural fever than species from thermally stable environments, consistent with the climate variability hypothesis, and that (ii) reptiles would exhibit stronger fever responses than amphibians due to lower hydrothermal constraints. Across 47 studies encompassing 103 effect sizes, we found that behavioural fever is widespread but highly context-dependent. We found that evidence for behavioural fever was strongest in species from more thermally variable habitats, regardless of body size and phylogeny, suggesting that access to thermally heterogeneous landscapes and enhanced behavioural plasticity amplify the capacity to sustain febrile responses. Contrary to our hypothesis, amphibians exhibited stronger fever responses than reptiles, possibly reflecting differences in baseline thermoregulatory demands and environmental opportunity, or as a consequence of methodological artefacts. The expression of behavioural fever also varied with pathogen identity, with bacterial infections eliciting larger body temperature increases than fungal or viral challenges, although pathogen representation was uneven across studies. Together, our results support the idea that the capacity to express behavioural fever depends on access to thermally heterogeneous landscapes, and may vary according to pathogen biology. Ultimately, our study emphasises that temperature is not a background condition for host-pathogen interactions, but an active and environmentally contingent component of ectotherm immune defence in amphibians and reptiles.