Towards the reliable use of aerial eDNA for ecosystem monitoring

Abstract

Evidence supporting the use of airborne eDNA for biodiversity studies and ecosystem monitoring is growing. The promise of wide-area population dynamics data for downstream applications in targeted monitoring of pests and pathogens for agriculture and rare species for conservation is appealing; however, several technical challenges persist. Here, we focused on the development of a comprehensive dataset to facilitate assay development and accelerate the use of aerial sampling for species detection. Year-round metabarcoding data was generated using bacterial, fungal, plant, and arthropod primer sets and resulted in relative abundance estimates for 4,960 amplicon sequence variants (ASVs), 1,748 ASVs of which were assigned to a minimum taxonomic level of genus (bacteria, fungi, plants) or class (arthropods). Sequence diversity assessments and seasonal clustering based on presence/absence detection patterns were performed for individual ASVs, while discerning quantitative changes in seasonal abundance required grouping ASVs to at least the genus level. Examination of the technical aspects of metabarcoding suggested that the use of subsampling allows for consistent detection of genera with relative abundance values above 2 %, even when samples have varying sequencing depths. Sequencing depth was the primary determinate for detecting sporadic and/or rare ASVs. Sampler comparisons, common sources of variation, and the benefits of barcoding regional species to supplement the existing taxonomic databases were discussed. Insufficient knowledge of sampler coverage area for the different organism types was identified as a limitation to the deployment of aerial monitoring networks. Considerations for further aerial metabarcoding efforts are suggested based on our experimental findings. ImportanceOur study deals directly with the generation, analysis and limitations of airborne eDNA metabarcoding data for re-use by the broader environmental research community. This includes timing of seasonal detection for possible genera of interest across multiple kingdoms, including bacteria, fungi, plants and animals (specifically arthropods), and support for the generation of local databases to assess the current limitations of universal primers for species/genus taxonomic resolution. With regards to methodology, it continues to build upon established best practices for airborne eDNA collection in areas such as sub-sampling and sampling replicates, sampler type and sequencing depth. To accelerate possible uptake and application of the data, we provide the identified ASVs and their seasonal relative abundances as a resource.