The reliability and accuracy of recombination inferred by Shapeit2 duoHMM on whole genome sequence

Abstract

Few studies assessed the performance of population-based phasing combined with parental genotypes to infer recombination on whole genome sequence (WGS) data. In this study, our objective was to evaluate whether Shapeit2 duoHMM, a Hidden Markov Model using parental genotypes, infers recombination events reliably on WGS and with narrower intervals than SNP arrays. We based our analysis on the overlap between recombination events inferred by Merlin on SNP genotypes and Shapeit2 on WGS and SNP genotypes. We used a sample of 61 extended families from the GeneSTAR study with TopMED freeze 8 WGS on 580 sequenced subjects (60% of sample). Shapeit2 was run with a window size of 500 kilobases and 200 states on WGS. To mimic a SNP array, we extracted genotypes of 355,112 autosomal markers on the Illumina OmniExpress array. The number of recombination events per meiosis inferred by Shapeit2 on the WGS data (36.8) was aligned with the expected numbers over autosomes (35.7), although Merlin overestimated this number (115.0). 73% of Shapeit2 recombination events on WGS were detected by Merlin, a proportion rising to 91% when restricting to events also inferred by Shapeit2 on OmniExpress genotypes. Furthermore, Shapeit2 recombination intervals were narrower on WGS than OmniExpress genotypes (median of 4,530 bp vs. 49,458 bp). This suggests that Shapeit2 on WGS is a reliable and accurate method for inferring recombination events.