Taxon appearance from extraction and amplification steps demonstrates the value of multiple controls in tick microbiome analysis

Abstract

BackgroundThe development of high throughput sequencing technologies has substantially improved analysis of bacterial community diversity, composition, and functions. Over the last decade, high throughput sequencing has been used extensively to identify the diversity and composition of tick microbial communities. However, a growing number of studies are warning about the impact of contamination brought along the different steps of the analytical process, from DNA extraction to amplification. In low biomass samples, e.g. individual tick samples, these contaminants may represent a large part of the obtained sequences, and thus generate considerable errors in downstream analyses and in the interpretation of results. Most studies of tick microbiota either do not mention the inclusion of controls during the DNA extraction or amplification steps, or consider the lack of an electrophoresis signal as an absence of contamination. In this context, we aimed to assess the proportion of contaminant sequences resulting from these steps. We analyzed the microbiota of individual Ixodes ricinus ticks by including several categories of controls throughout the analytical process: crushing, DNA extraction, and DNA amplification.\n\nResultsControls yielded a significant number of sequences (1,126 to 13,198 mean sequences, depending on the control category). Some operational taxonomic units (OTUs) detected in these controls belong to genera reported in previous tick microbiota studies. In this study, these OTUs accounted for 50.9% of the total number of sequences in our samples, and were considered contaminants. Contamination levels (i.e. the percentage of sequences belonging to OTUs identified as contaminants) varied with tick stage and gender: 76.3% of nymphs and 75% of males demonstrated contamination over 50%, while most females (65.7%) had rates lower than 20%. Contamination mainly corresponded to OTUs detected in crushing and DNA extraction controls, highlighting the importance of carefully controlling these steps.\n\nConclusionHere, we showed that contaminant OTUs from extraction and amplification steps can represent more than half the total sequence yield in sequencing runs, and lead to unreliable results when characterizing tick microbial communities. We thus strongly advise the routine use of negative controls in tick microbiota studies, and more generally in studies involving low biomass samples.