Adaptation to drought is coupled with slow growth in marginal silver fir (Abies alba Mill.) populations

Abstract

Drought is increasingly considered as the most important selection pressure for forest trees in the context of climate change. We studied adaptation to drought in marginal populations of silver fir (Abies alba Mill.) from the French Mediterranean Alps. Drought tolerance was assessed using proxies both from seedlings and adult trees. We measured water stress response, growth and bud break of seedlings originating from 16 populations in a greenhouse common garden experiment (N=8199) and water use efficiency via{delta} 13C of adult trees of the source populations in-situ (N=315). Further, 357 single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) were used to uncover the demographic history of the populations. Demographic distances between populations were used to generate a null expectation for trait divergence, thereby detect the signature of natural selection. We found evidence for adaptive population divergence in drought tolerance across life stages. Seedlings originating from source populations with low soil water capacity resisted better to water stress in the greenhouse, and additionally, adult trees from these populations had a higher water use efficiency. Seedling growth showed an evolutionary trade-off with drought tolerance: seedlings with fast growth and high stature came from populations that had lower drought tolerance. In contrast, population divergence in bud break showed only a weak signal of adaptation, which was independent of that in drought tolerance. Variation in phenology between populations was associated with variance in temperature and drought frequency and severity at the source populations. Our results highlight the adaptive value of marginal populations, advance our understanding of the different processes that have allowed silver fir to cope with drought stress under a warming climate, and contribute to our knowledge to advise assisted migration programs.