bioRxiv Science⌕ Search
Home/Archive/bioRxiv

bioRxiv · 10.1101/503300

Economic status mediates the relationship between educational attainment and posttraumatic stress disorder: a multivariable Mendelian randomization study

Polimanti, R.·Ratanatharathorn, A.·Maihofer, A. X.·Choi, K. W.·Stein, M. B.·Morey, R. A.·Logue, M. W.·Nievergelt, C.·Stein, D. J.·Koenen, K. C.·Gelernter, J.·the Psychiatric Genomics Consortium Posttraumatic Stress Disorder Workgroup,
View original source ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

ObjectivesTo investigate the genetic overlap and causal relationship between posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and traits related to educational attainment.\n\nDesignGenetic correlation, polygenic risk scoring, and causal inference via multivariable Mendelian randomization (MR).\n\nSettingPsychiatric Genomics Consortium for PTSD, UK Biobank, 23andMe, and Social Science Genetic Association Consortium.\n\nParticipants23,185 PTSD cases and 151,309 controls; up to 1,131,881 individuals assessed for educational attainment and related traits.\n\nMain outcome measuresGenetic correlation obtained from linkage disequilibrium score regression, phenotypic variance explained by polygenic risk scores, and casual effects (beta values) estimated with MR\n\nResultsPTSD showed strong negative genetic correlations with educational attainment (EdAtt; rg=-0.26, p=4.6x10-8). PRS based on genome-wide significant variants associated with EdAtt significantly predicted PTSD (p=6.16x10-4), but PRS based on variants associated with PTSD did not predict EdAtt (p>0.05). MR analysis indicated that EdAtt has negative causal effects on PTSD (beta=-0.23, p=0.004). Investigating potential mediators of the EdAtt-PTSD relationship, we observed that propensity for trauma exposure and risk-taking behaviors are risk factors for PTSD independently from EdAtt (beta = 0.36, p = 2.57x10-5 and beta = 0.76, p = 6.75x10-4, respectively), while income fully mediates the causal effect of EdAtt on PSTD (MR: Income - beta = -0.18, p =0.001; EdAtt - beta =-0.23, p=0.004; multivariable MR: Income - beta = -0.32, p = 0.017; EdAtt - beta = -0.04, p = 0.786).\n\nConclusionsWe report novel findings based on large-scale datasets regarding the relationship between educational attainment and PTSD, supporting the role of economic status as the key mediator in the causal relationship observed.\n\nWhat is already known on this topicThere is a well-established negative association of educational attainment and other traits related to cognitive ability with posttraumatic stress disorders (PTSD). However, the findings of these previous studies support various possible causal explanations: 1) individuals with high educational attainment are more resilient with respect to developing PTSD, 2) PTSD negatively impacts cognitive ability, or 3) PTSD and educational attainment share some underlying determinants, including relevant molecular mechanisms.\n\nA key obstacle to disentangling the complex association between educational attainment and PTSD is reverse causation, i.e. the situation in which the outcome precedes and causes the exposure instead of the other way around.\n\nWhat this study addsWe conducted a causal-inference investigation based on large-scale information from the investigation of more than one million individuals. Our main assumption is that genetic information can strongly minimize the bias of reverse causation, because genetic variants are determined at conception and do not change throughout life.\n\nOur findings indicate 1) the effect of traits related to educational attainment on PTSD, 2) no reverse effect of PTSD on educational attainment, and 3) economic status mediates the relationship between educational attainment and PTSD, independently from the brain mechanisms related to educational attainment.

Explore related subjects

geneticsPreprint

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Polimanti, R., Ratanatharathorn, A., Maihofer, A. X., Choi, K. W., Stein, M. B., Morey, R. A., Logue, M. W., Nievergelt, C., Stein, D. J., Koenen, K. C., Gelernter, J., the Psychiatric Genomics Consortium Posttraumatic Stress Disorder Workgroup,. 2018-12-21. Economic status mediates the relationship between educational attainment and posttraumatic stress disorder: a multivariable Mendelian randomization study. https://doi.org/10.1101/503300

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related preprints

bioRxiv2026

Transportability of mouse gene knockout models to human complex phenotypes

Mouse gene knockout studies are a valuable resource for understanding human gene function and the mechanisms underlying disease. However, translating insights to humans requires causal similarities between mouse and human phenotypes. A mouse model is transportable if gene perturbations that impact the mouse phenotype also affect (in orthologous genes) the corresponding human phenotype of interest, with consistent directionality. To assess the transportability of mouse models to human complex traits we combined laboratory mouse gene perturbation data from the high-throughput International Mouse Phenotyping Consortium with predicted loss-of-function data from the UK Biobank within the Gene Perturbation Analysis for Transportability (GPAT) framework. Applying GPAT to 30 matched mouse-human phenotype pairs, we found evidence of transportability for 12 mouse phenotypes including biochemical (e.g. total cholesterol), cellular (e.g. lymphocyte counts) and anthropometric (e.g. length/height) phenotypes. In contrast, there was limited evidence for others such as fat mass and body mass index in the context of the murine experimental conditions. We also found some evidence of transportability of mouse glucose measurements to diabetes mellitus in humans. Genome-wide perturbation effects on matched phenotypes were on average positively correlated between mice and humans (meta-analysis GPAT P = 2.3x10-27). However, the degree of correlation was generally modest and heterogeneous across phenotypes with some gene perturbations strongly associated in both species in opposite directions. Our framework illustrates how perturbation data can be used to quantitatively validate experimental models for understanding human disease aetiology and highlights the need for a range of orthogonal model systems, which may include challenges and perturbations to the mouse knockouts, to interrogate the mechanistic basis of human genetic associations.

genetics↗
bioRxiv2026

LRCQ: phenome-wide heritability enrichment of genomic loci from GWAS summary statistics

Some genetic variants are associated with many traits, but a variant's GWAS statistics are also inflated by the effects of variants in LD with it and by confounding shared by all variants in a study. Existing measures of per-variant pleiotropy, such as counts of significant associations or multi-trait association tests, do not separate these sources. Stratified LD score regression separates them for one trait at a time and only through predefined annotations. We present LRCQ (LD score regression on {chi}2 across many GWAS), which estimates for each locus its phenome-wide heritability enrichment: the variance of its causal effects across a set of traits, relative to an average locus. LRCQ regresses squared Z-scores from 30 or more GWAS jointly on squared LD, with per-trait LDSC intercepts and heritabilities fitted in earlier stages. Its pooled least-squares solution has a closed form whose cost does not grow with the number of traits. Its standard errors account for sample overlap and genetic correlation between GWAS. Squared Z-scores identify enrichment at the resolution of LD clumps, not single SNPs, so LRCQ reports clump-level estimates ("omni-loci"). These estimates can be aggregated over any functional annotation or gene set chosen after the analysis. In simulations with real UK Biobank LD and 30 to 1,000 traits, LRCQ was unbiased for its clump-level estimand. When GWAS share samples its test statistics are strongly right-skewed: normal-reference p-values were up to 10-fold anti-conservative at P < 0.001, and skewness-corrected p-values from the exact third cumulant restored type-I error and FDR control. Model-based standard errors were calibrated once the enrichment estimates plugged into them kept the polygenic background. It ranked enriched loci better than mean {chi}2, LD-normalised {chi}2, multi-trait omnibus tests and significant-association counts in 13 of 16 scenarios. Its main vulnerability was a misspecified LDSC intercept. Applied to 444 Pan-UK Biobank European-ancestry GWAS, LRCQ found strongly non-uniform phenome-wide enrichment: the SD of true clump-mean enrichment was 8.3, against a genome mean of 1. It identified 70 omni-loci (99 LD clumps) at FDR 5%, including CRP, CETP, APOB, AKTIP, SMOX, the SHBG region, CASZ1 and HNF1A. These ranked only moderately with mean {chi}2 and poorly with counts of significant associations. Gene-level phenome-wide enrichment rose with loss-of-function constraint. Phenome-wide heritability was 3-5-fold enriched in coding, conserved, 5' UTR and promoter sequence, and depleted in repressed chromatin. LRCQ turns hundreds of biobank GWAS into an LD-corrected map of where phenome-wide genetic variance lies, and complements its companion method LRCP, which estimates genetic-effect correlations between loci.

genetics↗