Parallel patterns of development between independent cases of hybrid seed inviability in Mimulus

Abstract

RationaleHybrid seed inviability (HSI) is a common reproductive barrier in angiosperms, yet the evolutionary and developmental drivers of HSI remain largely unknown. We test whether conflict between maternal and paternal interests in resource allocation to developing offspring (i.e. parental conflict) are associated with HSI and determine the degree of developmental parallelism between independent incidences of HSI in Mimulus.\n\nMethodsWe quantified HSI between M. guttatus and two clades of M. decorus with oppositely asymmetric incompatibilities and surveyed development of hybrid and parental seeds.\n\nKey ResultsCrosses between M. guttatus and both clades of M. decorus show parent-of-origin effects on reciprocal F1 seed development, but in opposing directions. Inviable hybrid seeds exhibit paternal excess phenotypes, wherein endosperm is large and chaotic while viable hybrid seeds produce endosperm cells that are smaller and less prolific (i.e. maternal-excess phenotypes).\n\nMain ConclusionsWe find strong parent-of-origin effects on development in reciprocal F1s in multiple incidences of HSI in Mimulus. These patterns suggest that parental conflict may be an important force generating HSI in this group, and mismatches between maternal and paternal contributions to developing seeds result in repeatable developmental defects in hybrids.