bioRxiv Science⌕ Search
Home/Archive/bioRxiv

bioRxiv · 10.1101/2025.11.05.686693

High-Concordance Validation of Droplet Digital PCR and Next-Generation Sequencing for EGFR Mutation Detection Across Diverse Biospecimens in a Large-scale NSCLC Cohort Study

Liu, M.·Lu, L.·Zhu, L.·Zhang, X.·Liu, Y.·Ren, X.·Liu, S.·Cheng, S.·Xu, M.·lu, C.·Peng, Y.·Su, W.·Guo, Y.·Chen, S.
View original source ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

BackgroundsNext-generation sequencing (NGS) and droplet digital PCR (ddPCR) are both established methods for detecting EGFR mutations in non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC). However, comprehensive validation of their concordance in mutation detection and variant allele frequency (VAF) quantification across heterogeneous sample types remains limited. Inconsistent results from different sample types (e.g., cfDNA, FFPE) pose a significant challenge to clinical decisions. This is particularly critical for advanced NSCLC patients, who often rely on liquid biopsy, yet the concordance between liquid and tissue-based testing lacks validation in large-scale studies. Another issue in clinical practice is that many tumor samples are limited in quantity, making it difficult to meet testing requirements. Therefore, it is worth exploring whether pre-capture NGS libraries can serve as substitutes for original DNA. MethodsIn this study, we first developed three assays to detect EGFR L858R, exon 19 deletions (Ex19del) and T790M, respectively using ddPCR platform. Their Limit of Detection (LOD) could reach 0.01% at 100 ng of input DNA. Subsequently, we conducted a large retrospective clinical study to systematically compare the detection performance of ddPCR and NGS across three mutation types using approximately 1,000 EGFR-positive samples, including cell-free DNA (cfDNA), pre-capture NGS libraries of cfDNA (cfDNA-prePCR), FFPE-derived DNA (ffpeDNA), pre-capture NGS libraries of FFPE-derived DNA (ffpeDNA-prePCR), fresh tumor tissue DNA (ttDNA), pre-capture NGS libraries of ttDNA (ttDNA-prePCR), pleural effusion supernatants DNA (peDNA), and pre-capture NGS libraries of peDNA (peDNA-prePCR). They were analyzed for detection concordance and VAF correlation. Especially, we made comparisons of the tumor DNA, including ctDNA and tumor tissue DNA, with their paired pre-capture NGS library. ResultsKey findings demonstrated excellent overall agreement between NGS and ddPCR. The mutation detection concordance rates were 98.72% (overall), with subtype-specific rates of 98.93% (L858R), 99.23% (Ex19del), and 97.14% (T790M). VAF measurements between ddPCR and NGS showed exceptional correlation (Pearsons r = 0.975, P<0.001). Notably, pre-capture NGS libraries showed remarkable VAF concordance with their source materials (0.993 for cfDNA libraries vs cfDNA; 0.998 for tumor tissue libraries vs tumor DNA with EGFR L858R; 0.991 for tumor tissue libraries vs tumor DNA with EGFR Ex19del). ConclusionsNGS and ddPCR demonstrate high concordance in EGFR mutation detection and VAF quantification, supporting their complementary roles in clinical testing. Using pre-capture libraries as an alternative to source samples can avoid repeat biopsies and enables subsequent testing for patients with inadequate FFPE sample quantity. These findings establish an evidence base for integrated diagnostic paradigms leveraging NGSs multiplexing power and ddPCRs sensitivity.

Explore related subjects

cancer biologyPreprint

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Liu, M., Lu, L., Zhu, L., Zhang, X., Liu, Y., Ren, X., Liu, S., Cheng, S., Xu, M., lu, C., Peng, Y., Su, W., Guo, Y., Chen, S.. 2025-11-07. High-Concordance Validation of Droplet Digital PCR and Next-Generation Sequencing for EGFR Mutation Detection Across Diverse Biospecimens in a Large-scale NSCLC Cohort Study. https://doi.org/10.1101/2025.11.05.686693

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related preprints

bioRxiv2026

A low-matrix organoid-T cell co-culture platform for functional evaluation of T cell engagers in patient-derived colorectal cancer organoids

Background Colorectal cancer (CRC) remains a leading cause of cancer-related mortality, and emerging T cell engager (TCE) immunotherapies require predictive preclinical models that capture patient-specific tumour biology and tumour-immune interactions. Although patient-derived organoid (PDO)-immune co-culture systems show promise for evaluating immunotherapy responses, many rely on matrix-embedded cultures that limit scalability and reproducibility. We therefore developed and validated a low-matrix organoid-T cell co-culture platform for functional assessment of TCE activity in patient-derived CRC models. Methods Patient-derived CRC organoids representing diverse molecular and genetic backgrounds were co-cultured with activated allogeneic CD3+ T cells in a suspension low-matrix format. Matrix concentration, medium composition, T cell activation status, and assay duration were optimized. Tumour killing, T cells activation, cytokine secretion, apoptosis, and motility were assessed using flow cytometry, live-cell imaging, cytokine profiling, and immunofluorescence. The platform was evaluated using EGFR- and HER2-targeting bispecific T cell engagers across 21 CRC organoid models and multiple healthy donor-derived T cell populations. Results Optimization identified 1% matrix and a 1:1 organoid: T cell medium that preserved organoid integrity while maintaining T cell viability, activation, and motility. The final workflow enabled reproducible co-culture of 5-day mature organoids with 7-day activated T cells for 72 hours. EGFR-targeting TCEs induced tumour killing, T cell activation, and IFN-{gamma} secretion across donor-organoid combinations. Screening of 21 CRC organoid models revealed substantial inter-patient heterogeneity, with 12 models maintaining [&ge;]50% baseline viability and supporting functional TCE evaluation. EGFR- and HER2-targeting TCEs produced potent dose-dependent cytotoxicity, with IC50 values ranging from 0.0188 to 54.77 nM across responsive models and up to 75%-85% tumour killing in the most sensitive organoids. These responses were accompanied by increased effector cytokine secretion. Real-time imaging confirmed dynamic T cell engagement and apoptosis-driven organoid destruction following TCE treatment. Conclusions We establish a robust, scalable, human-relevant low-matrix organoid-T cell co-culture platform for functional screening of T cell engagers in patient-derived CRC models. By enabling integrated assessment of tumour killing, immune activation, cytokine responses, and tumour-immune interactions while preserving inter-patient heterogeneity, this system provides a translational framework for immunotherapy development. The platform may support candidate prioritisation, biomarker discovery, patient stratification, and preclinical evaluation of immune-engaging therapeutics.

cancer biology↗
bioRxiv2026

MYC-Hyperactivated Osteosarcoma Models Exhibit Resistance to Cabozantinib plus TIGIT Blockade

Background: Relapsed and refractory osteosarcoma (OS) remains a major therapeutic challenge, with fewer than 20% of patients surviving beyond 3 years. Increasing evidence indicates that MYC amplification/overexpression is associated with inferior survival. Small molecule inhibitors and immunotherapies have limited single-agent efficacy in pediatric solid tumors. Using syngeneic cell lines derived from p53-driven and MYC-hyperactivated genetically engineered mouse models (GEMMs) of OS, we tested cabozantinib, a multi-tyrosine kinase inhibitor with immunomodulatory properties, with TIGIT immune checkpoint blockade and investigated mechanisms underlying therapeutic response and resistance. Methods: In vitro cabozantinib sensitivity was established in GEMM-derived cell lines. Mice bearing tibial tumors were randomized to vehicle control, cabozantinib, anti-TIGIT antibody, or combination therapy, and tumor growth and survival assessed after a 3-week treatment period. Temporal RNA sequencing was performed at early (8-15 days) and late (18-24 days) time points to characterize transcriptomic changes associated with efficacy. Results: MYC-hyperactivated cell lines were more resistant to cabozantinib in vitro than p53-driven lines (mean IC50 5.51 vs 0.65 mciroM, p=0.0016). In p53-driven orthotopic models, combination therapy significantly decreased tumor growth and improved survival compared to solvent and cabozantinib alone, while in MYC-hyperactivated models cabozantinib-containing regimens delayed tumor progression relative to control or anti-TIGIT monotherapy, however the addition of anti-TIGIT did not significantly improve survival over cabozantinib alone. Temporal transcriptomics revealed upregulated anti-tumor immune-response pathways and decreased M2 macrophages only with combination treatment in the p53-driven model. In contrast, combination-treated MYC-hyperactivated models demonstrated increased TNF signaling and elevated Cxcl5 and Ccr2 expression, indicative of increased myeloid cell recruitment, and upregulation of extracellular matrix (ECM) remodeling pathways suggest a therapy-induced stress adapted state that propagates treatment resistance over time. Conclusion: New therapies are needed for patients with relapse or refractory OS. By targeting tumor-intrinsic resistance mechanisms and modulating the tumor microenvironment using cabozantinib and anti-TIGIT therapy, improved tumor control and survival was achieved in p53-driven orthotopic OS models. MYC-hyperactivated models were able to overcome therapeutic pressure and employ myeloid recruitment and ECM remodeling programs to achieve treatment resistance. Targeting of these programs should be considered in future studies investigating therapeutic strategies in relapsed and refractory OS.

cancer biology↗
bioRxiv2026

Mitochondrial priming in human germ cell tumors is dependent on MCL1 and BCL2L1

Germ cell tumors (GCTs) are highly sensitized to cell death in response to DNA damaging agents, a property that underlies the success of current chemotherapeutic regimens. To address the molecular basis for this, known as apoptotic priming, we evaluated how different BCL2 family members modulate the heightened sensitivity of GCTs to therapy. Our analysis of human GCTs finds consistently high expression of the pro-survival factors MCL1 and BCL2L1 (BCLX) in a cohort of primary tumors and in their embryonic precursor cells, frequently accompanied by copy number gains of these loci and reciprocal losses of their pro-apoptotic interaction partners and inhibitors, PMAIP1 (NOXA) and BAD. We find that co-inhibition of MCL1 and BCLX using selective BH3 mimetics results in a potent synthetic lethality in multiple GCT embryonal carcinoma cell lines. When these cell lines were cultured with the DNA damaging agents cisplatin or etoposide, inhibition of MCL1 or BCLX potentiated their apoptotic effect in undifferentiated embryonal carcinoma cell lines, but not in retinoic acid-differentiated cells. The inhibition of MCL1 also heightened cisplatin sensitivity in p53-deficient or -mutant cell lines, which is associated with resistance to therapy. Employing an in ovo human xenograft model, we validate that the combination of cisplatin and MCL1 inhibition enhanced the therapeutic response by eliminating tumor cells. Our findings identify MCL1 and BCLX as critical factors to maintain GCT viability and as putative therapeutic targets to further augment GCT responsiveness to DNA damaging agents.

cancer biology↗