bioRxiv Science⌕ Search

bioRxiv · 10.1101/2025.09.08.674810

Accurate characterization of CRISPR-Cas9 genome editing outcomes and mosaicism with near-perfect long reads

Abstract

BackgroundGenetic mosaicism is a consequence of CRISPR-Cas9 genome editing that is difficult to study, especially when it involves structural variants occurring at low frequency. A comprehensive analysis of mosaicism requires deep and unbiased sequencing of the target loci, with accurate single molecule reads. Here we performed amplification-free PureTarget PacBio sequencing to investigate CRISPR-Cas9 outcomes at on-target and off-target sites in germline edited zebrafish and their offspring. ResultsThirty samples from pooled larvae and individual zebrafish were successfully sequenced, resulting in >1100x average target coverage. The PacBio reads reached an exceptional accuracy (QV39) over the target regions, with every read originating from a unique DNA molecule. The two haplotypes of the target loci displayed a balanced depth of coverage, while long-range PCR of the same samples resulted in skewed data. Further analysis of the PureTarget data revealed widespread genetic mosaicism in individual founder (F0) fish, with up to 18 distinct on-target events and 11 off-target events present in a single adult founder. Several CRISPR-Cas9 editing outcomes, including large structural variants and off-target mutations, were inherited to the F1 generation. Notably, as many as seven unique editing events were found among F1 juvenile offspring from a single founder pair, thereby confirming the presence of genetic mosaicism in germ cells of founder zebrafish. This implies that some consequences of CRISPR-Cas9 editing may emerge only in the second generation. We also analyzed DNA methylation but did not observe altered 5mC CpG signals in genome edited samples. ConclusionsPureTarget enables efficient, accurate and unbiased analysis of the full spectrum of genetic mosaicism in a sample. The potential risks of introducing germ cell mosaicism in founder individuals should be carefully evaluated when designing germline genome editing experiments.

Explore related subjects

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Höijer, I., van Schendel, R., Emmanouilidou, A., Östlund, R., Bunikis, I., Tijsterman, M., den Hoed, M., Ameur, A.. 2025-09-09. Accurate characterization of CRISPR-Cas9 genome editing outcomes and mosaicism with near-perfect long reads. https://doi.org/10.1101/2025.09.08.674810

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related preprints

Structural variation in repeat elements is widespread in normal human tissues and in tumorigenesis

Somatic mosaicism contributes to genomic variation, yet postzygotic structural variants remain under-characterized. We performed long- and short-read WGS from multiple individuals (n=47 normal tissues; n=168 samples) and identified mosaic structural variants in all individuals and germ layers, impacting a median 285.2 kb/genome. Nearly half of breakpoints were independently validated, with tissue distributions reflecting both early and late developmental origins. Most mosaic variants were repeat-mediated and 8.3% overlapped functional elements, an enrichment compared to germline variants. To extend these analyses in samples where long-read sequencing is infeasible, we measured repeat alterations from short-read sequencing, recapitulating mosaic tissue-specific differences. We characterized tumor- and tissue- specific variation in repeats across 15 cancer types and found tumor-related repeat variation to be similar in scale to that of normal mosaic variation. Tracking repeat changes in cell-free DNA provided a noninvasive approach for tumor monitoring. Our analyses revealed widespread repeat-driven structural variation in health and disease.

genomics↗

RNA isoform-resolved multiplexed sequencing with bioorthogonal barcoding

RNA isoform dysregulation drives disease pathogenesis and is the target of FDA-approved splice-switching therapeutics. However, multiplexed sequencing methods discard splice junction information because only 3' termini are barcoded and counted. Here, we repurpose acylation and click chemistries to conjugate bioorthogonal barcodes (bobcodes) directly onto multiple internal positions along cellular RNAs. Bobcoded RNAs from multiple samples are pooled for multiplexed cDNA synthesis, during which reverse transcriptase switches from each RNA template onto its tethered bobcode with greater than 99% accuracy in species mixing experiments. Bobcode attachment intervals set cDNA insert sizes without a library fragmentation step, and priming with poly(dT) or random hexamers selects between 3'-end counting and full-length isoform capture. A bioorthogonal barcode-sequencing (BOB-seq v0.1) drug screen identifies transcriptome-wide on- and off-target RNA splicing effects and outperforms existing multiplexing RNA sequencing methods in workflow simplicity, sample-to-sample variability, and barcoding accuracy. Bobcodes add isoform resolution to scalable multiplexed RNA sequencing.

genomics↗

Structural polymorphism and population-variable coding capacity of HERV-K(HML-2) in human pangenomes

Approximately 8% of the human genome is derived from ancient retroviral infections. The most recently integrated of these endogenous retroviruses is the HERV-K(HML-2) clade, whose expression has been associated with cancer, amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, and embryogenesis. Studies of HERV expression, particularly HML-2, have relied predominantly on short-read sequencing. However, the high similarity among HML-2 proviruses prevents many short reads from being assigned uniquely to individual loci. We therefore compared haplotype-resolved long-read genome assemblies from 292 donors to resolve variation in proviral structure and coding capacity. Several loci previously thought to be fixed were structurally polymorphic. Tandem arrays occurred at 13 loci and contained up to six proviral copies in a single array. At 8q11.23, we identified a previously undescribed full-length provirus in one haplotype. All 583 other haplotypes carried a solo-LTR. We found that standard reference genomes failed to represent the coding capacity retained in many individuals, whose proviruses contained intact open reading frames despite disruptive mutations in the reference sequences. Short-read genotypes left 32.5% of the tested donor-variant pairs unresolved at sites associated with viral reading frames. These findings show why HML-2 expression must be interpreted in the context of the structural and coding alleles each individual carries.

genomics↗