Comparative analysis of the radiobiological effects of laser-driven VHEE vs. conventional electrons using in vitro, ex vivo, and in vivo models

Abstract

PurposeThis study systematically investigates the radiobiological effects of Very High Energy Electrons (VHEE) generated by a laser-plasma accelerator (LPA), in comparison with Conventional Intermediate Energy Electrons (CIEE) from a conventional linear accelerator (LINAC). Using in vitro, ex vivo, and in vivo models, we evaluate and compare their potential toxicity on healthy tissues. Methods and MaterialsCell survival, tissue response, and developmental toxicity were assessed across three biological models. In vitro, human fibroblasts (MRC5-hTERT) were used to generate post-irradiation survival curves. Ex vivo, precision-cut lung slices (PCLS) from mice were analyzed for radiation-induced inhibition of cell proliferation. In vivo, zebrafish embryos were used to evaluate developmental toxicity through body length and spinal curvature measurements. VHEE irradiations were performed using a broadband electron beam spanning 50-300 MeV, using the Salle Jaune LPA (Laboratoire dOptique Appliquee, France), while CIEE exposures were performed with a 7 MeV conventional LINAC (Institut Curie, France). ResultsIn vitro, MRC5-hTERT cells showed no significant difference in radiosensitivity between VHEE and CIEE, with comparable D10 values (p-value = 0.7). In the ex vivo model, both beams induced a dose-dependent decrease in cell division with no significant inter-beam differences at any dose level (p-value > 0.99). In vivo, zebrafish embryos exhibited dose-dependent body shortening and increased spinal curvature following both VHEE and CIEE exposure. No significant differences were observed between the two modalities at matched doses for any measured metric (p-value[≥] 0.5). ConclusionThis study presents the first comprehensive radiobiological evaluation of a laser-driven VHEE beam across multiple biological models. Under the investigated conditions, VHEE and CIEE irradiations exhibit similar biological toxicity. These findings support the feasibility and potential of VHEE generated with LPA for future clinical applications.