Tensions in tillage: Reduction in tillage intensity associates with lower wheat growth and nutritional grain quality despite enhanced soil biological indicators

Waibel, M.; Michel, J.; Antoine, M.; Balanzategui-Guijarro, I.; Cao, D.; Delaplace, P.; Le Gouis, J.; Alvarez, D.; Leon, C.; Manfroy, S.; Moya-Larano, J.; Perrochon, S.; Sanchez-Moreno, S.; Santin-Montanya, I.; Tenorio, J. L.; Thonar, C.; Vanderschuren, H.; Van Der Straeten, D.; Verlinde, T.; Weinmann, M.; Symanczik, S.

doi:10.1101/2024.12.09.627503

Home/Archive/bioRxiv

bioRxiv · 10.1101/2024.12.09.627503

Tensions in tillage: Reduction in tillage intensity associates with lower wheat growth and nutritional grain quality despite enhanced soil biological indicators

View original source ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

Dryland ecosystems are particularly susceptible to the adverse effects of intensive agriculture, with intensive tillage exerting a major impact on soil health and its biotic components. The implementation of less disturbing soil management practices can be essential for preserving the soil environment and maintaining the diverse communities of microorganisms, micro- and mesofauna, which are essential contributors to soil fertility. In this study, we assessed soil chemical properties, soil biodiversity and functionality, and wheat crop growth across a tillage gradient encompassing no-tillage (NT), minimum tillage (MT), and standard tillage (ST). Results showed that NT resulted in increased soil macronutrient levels compared to MT and ST. In general, reduced tillage increased the abundance of soil biota, with significantly higher levels of bacterial and fungal marker genes observed in MT and NT compared to ST. Nematode abundance increased by 25% in MT and 50% in NT, compared to ST and predatory acari were significantly more abundant in NT, while numbers of total acari were higher in both NT and ST compared to MT. Community structure analysis revealed that tillage strongly influenced bacterial, fungal and acari community composition, reflecting a gradient of soil disturbance intensity. Corresponding to the increased abundance of soil biota, reduced tillage increased microbial activity and soil functionality along the disturbance gradient. This was evident in the potential activity of carbon, nitrogen and phosphorus cycling enzymes, as well as the microbial capacity for carbon utilisation. In addition, evidence of the formation of biocrust as a possible source of carbon input was found. Furthermore, we observed important wheat pathogens to decrease and fungal antagonists to increase in NT compared to ST. Despite enhanced soil biological indicators under reduced tillage, wheat growth, nitrogen uptake and grain B vitamin contents were higher in ST compared to NT. In addition, we observed a shift in technological grain properties across tillage practices. The higher root:shoot ratio (an indicator of nitrogen deficiency) and median root diameter (hormone-driven lateral expansion) in NT suggest that soil compaction could be a potential cause of reduced wheat performance. These results suggest that despite improved soil biological indicators, other factors such as a low rates of N mineralization potential and prevalence of soil compaction may be limiting wheat performance in NT systems. HighlightsO_LIEnhanced microbial activity and functionality under reduced tillage C_LIO_LITillage intensity shaped community structure of microbes, nematodes and acari C_LIO_LISoil biocrust development under NT may increase soil organic carbon C_LIO_LIRoot traits revealed soil compaction and nutrient limitation in NT systems C_LIO_LIReduced tillage impaired wheat quality and changed technological grain properties C_LI

Source connections

Published article ↗

Explore related subjects

ecology Preprint

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeX RIS

Waibel, M., Michel, J., Antoine, M., Balanzategui-Guijarro, I., Cao, D., Delaplace, P., Le Gouis, J., Alvarez, D., Leon, C., Manfroy, S., Moya-Larano, J., Perrochon, S., Sanchez-Moreno, S., Santin-Montanya, I., Tenorio, J. L., Thonar, C., Vanderschuren, H., Van Der Straeten, D., Verlinde, T., Weinmann, M., Symanczik, S.. 2024-12-13. Tensions in tillage: Reduction in tillage intensity associates with lower wheat growth and nutritional grain quality despite enhanced soil biological indicators. https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.12.09.627503

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related preprints

bioRxiv2026

A leaf-carbon economy model to explain the adaptive value of low vs. high leaf mass per area as a function of habitat productivity

Plant traits interact with environmental conditions to determine plant fitness. In particular, plant species with low leaf mass per area (LMA) are more common in high fertility soils and forest gaps, while plant species with high LMA are more common in low fertility soils and in shaded forest understories. It is not yet known why the adaptive value of LMA changes as a function of environmental productivity. We present a model for plant growth as a function of LMA and productivity. Our model relies on an empirically derived relationship between LMA and leaf lifespan. We are able to explain why species with lower LMA are successful in high productivity environments including environments with high availability of either light or soil nutrients, by showing that the LMA which maximizes growth rate decreases with increasing rate of carbon assimilation. We show that low LMA species are better at taking advantage of the 'high interest' environment of high productivity habitats by reinvesting assimilated carbon in new leaves and earning compound interest, while high LMA species grow more efficiently in the 'low interest' environment of low productivity habitats. This tradeoff sheds light on the adaptive value of LMA as it relates to environmental productivity.

ecology↗

bioRxiv2026

Species differentiate water uptake depths within a narrow vertical zone in temperate grasslands

Whether and under which conditions coexisting species in temperate grasslands differentiate their water uptake within the shallow soil layer they share is central to understanding hydrological niche differentiation in these ecosystems. In this field study, we quantified water uptake depth of 28 coexisting herbaceous species across 74 temperate grassland plots in three regions of Germany using oxygen stable isotopes and soil water content measured at multiple depths. Species consistently differed in water uptake depth across all regions, consistent with hydrological niche differentiation. This differentiation was largely confined to the upper 30 cm of soil and became stronger as overall soil moisture declined, with plants accessing water at greater depths in drier plots. In contrast, the vertical distribution of soil moisture was unrelated to either uptake depth or species differentiation. Despite pronounced species level variation, broad herbaceous functional classifications, including grasses versus forbs and fibrous versus taprooted species, showed substantial overlap in water uptake depth. Together, our results show that hydrological niche differentiation in temperate grasslands is expressed through fine scale differences among species within a shared shallow soil domain, becomes more pronounced under drier conditions, and is poorly captured by broad herbaceous functional classifications.

ecology↗

bioRxiv2026

Fungal-bacterial interactions enhance bacterial but constrain fungal resistance and recovery to extreme heat across soil moisture levels

Soil fungi and bacteria are key drivers of nutrient cycling and plant productivity in terrestrial ecosystems, yet their responses to climate extremes are rarely studied as interacting partners rather than in isolation. Moreover, it remains largely unknown how fungal-bacterial interactions regulate fungal and bacterial stability under climate extremes, particularly resistance (immediate responses to climate extremes) and recovery (responses after climate extremes cease). Here, we conducted a soil microcosm experiment with a bacterial species (Pseudomonas putida KT2440) paired with one of four Trichoderma species (T. hamatum, T. atroviride, T. koningiopsis, and T. harzianum). These fungal-bacterial pairs were then exposed to a 5-day heat event (40 {degrees}C/32 {degrees}C, day/night) followed by a 14-day recovery period (25 {degrees}C/17 {degrees}C, day/night), at two soil moisture levels (30% and 5% gravimetric water content). Our results show that fungal-bacterial interactions asymmetrically affect fungal and bacterial responses to extreme heat. Trichoderma species facilitated the resistance and recovery of P. putida density (CFUs) to extreme heat, whereas P. putida constrained the resistance and recovery of fungal biomass (ergosterol) to extreme heat, regardless of soil moisture conditions. Moreover, faster-growing Trichoderma species were associated with greater facilitation of bacterial resistance and recovery. Bacterial density also covaried positively with fungal biomass during heat stress under both soil moisture conditions, suggesting that net fungal facilitation enhances bacterial persistence under extreme heat. Together, our findings reveal that fungal-bacterial interactions can stabilize one microbial partner while increasing the vulnerability of the other, highlighting the contrasting consequences of biotic interactions under climate extremes.

ecology↗