bioRxiv Science⌕ Search
Home/Archive/bioRxiv

bioRxiv · 10.1101/2024.10.02.614907

The Impact of Clinical and Molecular Variant Properties on Calibration and Performance of Variant Effect Prediction Tools

Isakov, O.·Ben-Shachar, S.
View original source ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

BackgroundVariant Effect Prediction (VEP) tools are essential for determining the potential pathogenicity of genetic variants, aiding clinical diagnostics and genetic counseling. However, their performance can vary depending on molecular and clinical contexts, complicating variant classification. AimThis study aims to assess the performance variability of commonly used VEP tools under different conditions. Additionally, the study aims to recalibrate score thresholds to better reflect evidence of pathogenicity. MethodsClinVar variants classified as pathogenic (P), likely pathogenic (LP), benign (B), or likely benign (LB) were analyzed using 25 VEP tools. Tools were evaluated based on discriminatory performance. Data were stratified by variant creation date, allele frequency, conservation level, mode of inheritance (MOI), and disease category. For each subset, Bayesian methods were employed to recalibrate score thresholds corresponding to the levels of evidence defined by the American College of Medical Genetics (ACMG). ResultsThe performance of VEP tools varied significantly across different subsets. Variants created after 2020 showed a mild yet significant decrease in the performance of certain VEP tools, particularly those trained on earlier datasets. VEP tools exhibited reduced accuracy for variants with higher allele frequencies, particularly those exceeding a frequency of 10-4, suggesting a need for recalibration when assessing more common variants. Tools demonstrated lower discriminatory performance for variants located in regions with high conservation, mostly due to a decrease in specificity. Variants affecting autosomal recessive (AR) and X-linked (XL) genes were more accurately classified compared to those affecting autosomal dominant (AD) genes by most tools. Differences in MOI and conservation levels within certain disease categories were shown to correlate with overall performance. Recalibration of prediction scores resulted in lower score thresholds in low conservation regions compared to high and uncovered subsets in which higher levels of evidence may be achieved. ConclusionVEP tools exhibit context-dependent performance variability, necessitating score recalibration for accurate classification.

Explore related subjects

bioinformaticsPreprint

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Isakov, O., Ben-Shachar, S.. 2024-10-03. The Impact of Clinical and Molecular Variant Properties on Calibration and Performance of Variant Effect Prediction Tools. https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.10.02.614907

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related preprints

bioRxiv2026

A meta-interaction basis for cell-cell communication in tissues

Tissue function depends on signals exchanged between cells and the responses they elicit. Yet whether diverse cell-cell interactions in situ form recurrent sender-receiver programs remains unclear. We present SpiderNet, an interpretable representation-learning framework that discovers such directed programs as a compact basis of cell-cell meta-interactions (MIs) from spatial transcriptomics. SpiderNet jointly learns which sender regulators, ligand-receptor pairs, and receiver targets define each MI and where each program is active across neighboring cell pairs. The resulting representation traces multicellular relays and links communication to cell states, perturbation responses, and phenotypes. SpiderNet recovers ground-truth MIs and their molecular components in simulations and, in real tissues, shows stronger direction-specific agreement with independently curated regulatory programs in senders and receivers than alternative methods. Across more than 5.8 million spatially profiled cells, SpiderNet resolves an SPP1-THBS relay linking monocytes, fibroblasts, and tumor cells within an immune-suppressive ovarian cancer niche, predicts T-cell responses to held-out melanoma-cell perturbations, and identifies a T-cell-associated brain-aging program and age-predictive signals that transfer across regions and platforms. It reveals a recurrent pan-cancer COLLAGEN-linked fibroblast-tumor program whose projected abundance in independent cohorts is associated with poorer survival and non-response to immunotherapy. SpiderNet thus establishes MIs as a reusable organizational layer between molecular interactions and tissue phenotypes, providing a framework to resolve, compare, trace, and perturb multicellular regulation in situ.

bioinformatics↗
bioRxiv2026

Heterogeneous Graph Contrastive Learning for Drug-Gene-Disease Motif Prediction

Drug repurposing and target discovery offer critical strategies for advancing therapeutic development by uncovering the potential biological pathways and novel associations among drugs, genes, and diseases. However, experimental discovery remains expensive and time-consuming, which limits the scalability of large-scale studies. In addition, existing computational approaches often struggle to effectively integrate heterogeneous biomedical data, capture the complex higher-order topological signatures of biological interactomes, and generalize to unseen entities. Here, we present HANAMI (Heterogeneous grAph coNtrastive leArning for drug-gene-disease Motif predIction), a multi-view deep graph learning framework designed to model complex interactions among drugs, genes, and diseases. HANAMI integrates diverse heterogeneous biomedical knowledge, including chemical structures, genomic sequences, and clinical phenotypes, and leverages relation-aware topology encoding, structure-aware aggregation, and contrastive learning to enable accurate motif prediction with biological context from the network. Systematic evaluation on benchmark datasets shows that HANAMI achieves up to 6% improvements over existing state-of-the-art methods in predicting drug-gene-disease motifs. The framework further demonstrates strong inductive generalization, maintaining an [~]18% performance advantage in zero-shot settings involving previously unseen entities. Beyond predictive performance, HANAMI effectively prioritizes drug-disease relationships investigated in Phase II or III trials while identifying candidate genes that suggest plausible mechanistic links. Together, HANAMI provides a computational framework for interpreting complex biomedical interactions, offering a scalable foundation to accelerate drug repurposing and therapeutic innovation.

bioinformatics↗
bioRxiv2026

PTMExplorer: A Multi-Dimensional Integrative Visualization Platform for Protein Post-Translational Modification Function and Structure

Deciphering the functions of post-translational modifications (PTMs) is a critical bridge connecting large-scale modification proteomics data to mechanistic studies. However, most existing tools for visualizing PTM omics data are limited to site catalogs or single-dimensional feature displays. They lack the capability to simultaneously map user-derived differential modification sites onto multi-dimensional contexts, including protein three-dimensional (3D) structure, evolutionary conservation, functional sites, and disease associations. This limitation makes it difficult for researchers to rapidly assess the biological importance of candidate sites from among a vast number of differentially modified sites. Here, we present PTMExplorer, an interactive platform for the multi-dimensional visualization of protein PTMs. PTMExplorer comprises three core modules: PTM Inspector, built upon ProtVista, provides a multi-track, sequence-feature integrated view incorporating intrinsically disordered region (IDR) prediction (via flDPnn), surface accessibility calculation (via FreeSASA), and UniProt functional annotations; PTM 3D Locator, leveraging the Nightingale/Mol* engine, anchors modification sites onto AlphaFold/Protein Data Bank (PDB) 3D structures through residue mapping via PDBe-SIFTS; and PTM Overview, utilizing the R circlize package, presents a panoramic polar circos plot illustrating modification distribution and inter-group differential regulation. Additionally, three major disease-associated modification databases (PTMD, qPTM, and PhosCancer) are integrated as PTM-Disease Nexus, enabling co-localization comparison between user-defined differential sites and reported disease-related sites. PTMExplorer currently supports eight model organisms, accepts user-uploaded differential analysis results, and provides multi-dimensional annotations and various visualization options (https://www.bioladder.cn/PTMExplorer/). Using a multi-omics dataset from hepatocellular carcinoma (18 patients, 9 modification types) as a case study, we demonstrate the practical utility of PTMExplorer in screening potential biomarkers, revealing multi-modification coordination mechanisms, and distinguishing between absolute and relative quantification patterns.

bioinformatics↗