Endosymbionts impact ladybird predation rates of aphids in a temperature-dependent manner

Abstract

Aphids are worldwide pests causing major economic losses to growers. Current management strategies rely heavily on pesticides, but some effective pesticides are being withdrawn and the efficiency of remaining pesticides is also decreasing as aphids build up resistance. Biological control using predators can provide a sustainable alternative to pesticides under some circumstances, while the deliberate introduction of facultative bacterial endosymbionts that induce host fitness costs and reduce plant virus transmission provides another potential future strategy to combat aphid pests. However, new control options should not be antagonistic, with the concern that the effectiveness of biocontrol might be altered by endosymbiont presence in hosts. We, therefore, tested if predation by two aphidophagous ladybirds, Adalia bipunctata and Harmonia conformis, on the green peach aphid, Myzus persicae, and the oat aphid, Rhopalosiphum padi, was affected by transinfected Rickettsiella viridis and both native and transinfected Regiella insecticola endosymbionts at different temperatures. The predation rate of aphids infected by either endosymbiont was higher at 14 {degrees} C than the rate for uninfected aphids of both species, but the opposite pattern was apparent at 20 {degrees}C and for one host-endosymbiont combination at 26 {degrees}C. Overall, the results showed that higher temperatures increased predation, while differences between intermediate and low temperatures were species-dependent. No transmission of endosymbionts from aphid to ladybird through predation was detected. These findings point to a lack of consistent effects of the investigated endosymbionts on predation rates in these major aphid pests. The temperature dependence of endosymbiont-predation interactions suggests that the impact of seasonal climate should be considered when assessing the potential of endosymbionts in a biological control setting. HIGHLIGHTS- Aphid endosymbiont effects on ladybird predation rates are temperature-dependent - Ladybird predation rate of aphids increases as temperature rises - Prey (aphid) endosymbionts are not transferred to predators (ladybirds)