Ground nesting of soft eggs by extinct birds and a new parity mode switch hypothesis for the evolution of animal reproduction

Abstract

Nearshore ground nesting of soft eggs by extinct birds is demonstrated here, providing a new explanation for the abundance of bird fossils in early Cretaceous lacustrine environments, where humidity conditions required for soft egg incubation would have been present. This reinforces recent findings of Archaeopteryx soft eggs near Jurassic marine environments, the possibility that wings and elongated feathers developed primarily in association with nest protection on the ground and only secondarily with flight, and the origin of flight from the ground up. Notably, soft eggs preceded rigid eggs in evolution, but both crocodiles, whose ancestors seem to have antedated bird precursors, and extant birds reproduce exclusively via hard-shelled eggs. Therefore, an explanation is in order for how reproduction via soft eggs could have occurred in the bird lineage in-between two evolutionary moments of reproduction via rigid eggs. In alternative to the commonly accepted convergent evolution of viviparity and rigid eggshells, a parity mode switch hypothesis is presented here. It postulates the existence, since the rise of animals, of an inherited ancestral parity mode switch between viviparity and oviparity. This switch would have evolved to embrace hard-shelled oviparity after rigid eggshells appeared in evolution. Commitment to a particular parity mode or eggshell type may have conditioned survival of entire animal groups, especially during major extinction events, explaining, among others, the extinction of all birds that reproduced via soft eggshells.