Taxonomic distribution of SbmA/BacA and BacA-like antimicrobial peptide transporters suggests independent recruitment and convergent evolution in host-microbe interactions

Abstract

Small, antimicrobial peptides are often produced by eukaryotes to control bacterial populations in both pathogenic and mutualistic symbioses. These include proline-rich mammalian immune peptides and cysteine-rich peptides produced by legume plants in symbiosis with rhizobia. The fitness of the bacterial partner is dependent upon their ability to persist in the presence of these antimicrobial peptides. In the case of Escherichia coli and Mycobacterium tuberculosis pathogens and nitrogen-fixing legume symbionts (rhizobia), the ability to survive exposure to these peptides depends on peptide transporters called SbmA (also known as BacA) or BclA (for BacA-like). However, how broadly these transporters are distributed amongst bacteria, and their evolutionary history, is poorly understood. Here, we used hidden Markov models, phylogenetic analysis, and sequence similarity networks to examine the distribution of SbmA/BacA and BclA proteins across a representative set of 1,255 species from across the domain Bacteria. We identified a total of 71 and 177 SbmA/BacA and BclA proteins, respectively. Phylogenetic and sequence similarity analyses suggest that these protein families likely did not evolve from a common ancestor and that their functional similarity is instead a result of convergent evolution. In vitro sensitivity assays using the legume peptide NCR247 and several of the newly-identified BclA proteins confirmed that transport of antimicrobial peptides is a common feature of this protein family. Analysis of the taxonomic distribution of these proteins showed that SbmA/BacA orthologs were encoded only by species in the phylum Pseudomonadota and that they were primarily identified in just two orders: Hyphomicrobiales (class Alphaproteobacteria) and Enterobacterales (class Gammaproteobacteria). BclA orthologs were somewhat more broadly distributed and were found in clusters across four phyla. These included several orders of the phyla Pseudomonadota and Cyanobacteriota, as well as the order Mycobacteriales (phylum Actinomycetota) and the class Negativicutes (phylum Bacillota). Notably, many of the clades enriched for species encoding BacA or BclA orthologs also include many species known to interact with eukaryotic hosts in mutualistic or pathogenic interactions. Collectively, these observations suggest that SbmA/BacA and BclA proteins have been repeatedly co-opted to facilitate both mutualistic and pathogenic associations with eukaryotic hosts by allowing bacteria to cope with host-encoded antimicrobial peptides.