Robust and Accurate Doublet Detection of Single-Cell Sequencing Data via Maximizing Area Under Precision-Recall Curve

Abstract

Single-cell sequencing has revolutionized our understanding of cellular heterogeneity by offering detailed profiles of individual cells within diverse specimens. However, due to the limitations of sequencing technology, two or more cells may be captured in the same droplet and share the same barcode. These incidents, termed doublets or multiplets, can lead to artifacts in single-cell data analysis. While explicit experimental design can mitigate these issues with the help of auxiliary cell markers, computationally annotating doublets has a broad impact on analyzing the existing public single-cell data and reduces potential experimental costs. Considering that doublets form only a minor fraction of the total dataset, we argue that current doublet detection methods, primarily focused on optimizing classification accuracy, might be inefficient in performing well on the inherently imbalanced data in the area under the precision-recall curve (AUPRC) metric. To address this, we introduce RADO (Robust and Accurate DOublet detection) - an algorithm designed to annotate doublets by maximizing the AUPRC, effectively tackling the imbalance challenge. Benchmarked on 18 public datasets, RADO outperforms other methods in terms of doublet score and achieves similar performance to the current best methods in doublet calling. Furthermore, beyond its application in single-cell RNA-seq data, we demonstrate RADOs adaptability to single-cell assays for transposase-accessible chromatin sequencing (scATAC-seq) data, where it outperforms other scATAC-seq doublet detection methods. RADOs open-source implementation is available at: https://github.com/poseidonchan/RADO.