A diversity of diversities: evaluating the relationships between below and aboveground biodiversity

Abstract

O_LITo predict how biodiversity will respond to global change, it is crucial to understand the relative roles of abiotic drivers and biotic interactions in driving associations between the biodiversity of disparate taxa. It is particularly challenging to understand diversity-diversity links across domains and habitats, because data are rarely available for multiple above- and below-ground taxa across multiple sites. C_LIO_LIHere we analyse data from a unique biodiversity dataset gathered across a variety of oceanic temperate terrestrial habitats in Wales, comprising 300 sites with co-located soil microbial, plant, bird, and pollinator surveys along with climate and soil physicochemical information. Soil groups are analysed using metabarcoding of the 16S, ITS1 and 18S DNA regions, allowing in depth characterisation of microbial and soil animal biodiversity. C_LIO_LIWe explore biodiversity relationships along three aspects of community composition: First, we assess correlation between the alpha diversity of different groups. Second, we assess whether biotic turnover between sites is correlated across different groups. Finally, we investigate the co-occurrence of individual taxa across sites. In each analysis, we assess the contribution of linear or non-linear environmental effects. C_LIO_LIWe find that a positive correlation between alpha diversity of plants, soil bacteria, soil fungi, soil heterotrophic protists, bees and butterflies is in fact driven by complex non-linear responses to abiotic drivers. In contrast, environmental variation did not account for positive associations between the diversity of plants and both birds and AM fungi, suggesting a role for biotic interactions. C_LIO_LIBoth the diversity and taxon-level associations between the differing soil groups remained even after accounting for non-linear environmental gradients. Aboveground, spatial factors played larger roles in driving biotic communities, while linear environmental gradients were sufficient to explain many group- and taxon-level relationships. C_LIO_LISynthesis. Our results show how non-linear responses to environmental gradients drive many of the relationships between plant biodiversity and the biodiversity of above- and belowground biological communities. Our work shows how different aspects of biodiversity might respond non-linearly to changing environments and identifies cases where management-induced changes in one community could either influence other taxa or lead to loss of apparent biological associations. C_LI