Understanding inter-individual social networks in mixed-species bird flocks

Abstract

Mixed-species flocks (MSFs) are an important form of social organisation in forest bird communities worldwide. MSFs provide participants with the benefits of reduced predation risk and/or enhanced foraging efficiency. Recent work has shown that participation in MSFs confers long-term survival benefits in the face of anthropogenic change. However, our understanding of MSFs mainly comes from studies that examine species-level networks, where each node is a unique species and the edges or connections between nodes are associations/interactions between species. While valuable, such approaches might not allow us to understand and investigate the mechanisms that drive MSF formation and structure because social interactions and their effects occur at the individual-level. Empirical studies on multi-species, individual-level MSF social networks have seldom been undertaken due to the various complexities and logistical challenges involved. In this study, we use mist-netting and colour-ringing followed by a standardised observation protocol to construct individual-level social networks in MSFs at 2000m ASL in Eaglenest Wildlife Sanctuary, Arunachal Pradesh, Eastern Himalaya, India. First, we found two separate flocktypes at our study site, comprising two distinct sets of understorey species. The mechanisms contributing to individual-level co-occurrences are likely to differ between these flocktypes, and with MSFs in the Neotropics. The Rusty-fronted Barwing (the nuclear species of one flocktype) shows spatially disjunct territories for each flock while the Yellow-throated Fulvetta (nuclear species of the other flocktype) shows large spatial overlap in its MSF networks, which is likely driven by non-individual-specific benefits such as predation risk dilution. Further, the addition of associating individuals to the social networks has opposite impacts on the two networks. The addition of Coral-billed Scimitar Babblers to the barwing networks greatly reduces network modularity because the associating individuals bridge two modules of barwings (both spatially and in the social network). On the contrary, territorial Rufous-capped Babblers and Grey-cheeked Warblers increase the modularity of the spatially overlapping fulvetta network. Our study provides novel insights into flock formation mechanisms in the Eastern Himalaya, likely applicable to other multi-species flock systems in the Old World.