Closely related Bacteroides of the murine intestinal microbiota affect each other's growth positively or negatively

Fokt, H.; Sakalyte, G.; Unni, R.; Abukhalaf, M.; Cassidy, L.; Marinos, G.; Godfroid, M.; Kinfu, B. M.; Schmitz, R. A.; Kaleta, C.; Tholey, A.; Baines, J. F.; Dagan, T.; Unterweger, D.

doi:10.1101/2023.03.05.530569

bioRxiv · 10.1101/2023.03.05.530569

Closely related Bacteroides of the murine intestinal microbiota affect each other's growth positively or negatively

Fokt, H.·Sakalyte, G.·Unni, R.·Abukhalaf, M.·Cassidy, L.·Marinos, G.·Godfroid, M.·Kinfu, B. M.·Schmitz, R. A.·Kaleta, C.·Tholey, A.·Baines, J. F.·Dagan, T.·Unterweger, D.

View original source ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

The mammalian intestine is a unique ecosystem for thousands of bacterial species and strains. How naturally coexisting bacteria of the microbiota interact with each other is not yet fully understood. Here, we isolated formerly coexisting, closely related strains of the genus Bacteroides from the intestines of healthy, wild-derived mice. The effect of one strain on another strains growth was tested in 169 pairs in vitro. We find a vast diversity of growth promoting and growth inhibiting activities. A strong positive effect was observed between two strains with differing metabolisms. Growth inhibition among a subset of strains was associated with the known bacterial toxin bacteroidetocin B. Across all strains, we observed growth promotion more often than growth inhibition. The effects were independent of two strains belonging to the same or different species. In some cases, one species differed in its effect on another according to host origin. These findings on obligate host-associated bacteria demonstrate that closely related and naturally coexisting strains have the potential to affect each others growth positively or negatively. These results have implications for our basic understanding of host-associated microbes and the design of synthetic microbial communities.

Explore related subjects

microbiology Preprint

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeX RIS

Fokt, H., Sakalyte, G., Unni, R., Abukhalaf, M., Cassidy, L., Marinos, G., Godfroid, M., Kinfu, B. M., Schmitz, R. A., Kaleta, C., Tholey, A., Baines, J. F., Dagan, T., Unterweger, D.. 2023-03-05. Closely related Bacteroides of the murine intestinal microbiota affect each other's growth positively or negatively. https://doi.org/10.1101/2023.03.05.530569

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related preprints

bioRxiv2026

A population-scale landscape of the subgingival microbiome reveals divergent routes to periodontal dysbiosis

Periodontitis is an archetypical mucosal inflammatory disease in which microbiome dysbiosis at the tooth-epithelial interface interacts with host genetic and behavioral risk factors to drive immune-mediated tissue destruction. Although subgingival microbiome compositional shifts are thought to parallel disease severity, microbiome variation at the population-level and its relationship to periodontal clinical phenotypes and disease-modifying factors remain poorly defined. Here, we use unsupervised manifold learning to map the compositional landscape of the subgingival microbiome in 1,355 adults spanning periodontal health to severe periodontitis. We identified eight latent microbiome states organized along a branching continuum from eubiosis to dysbiosis. An intermediate microbial configuration marked ecological destabilization and bifurcation into two distinct periodontitis-associated dysbiotic trajectories, distinguished by links to gingival inflammation and smoking. Although the microbiome trajectories broadly tracked periodontal destruction, a minority of individuals showed discordant microbiome-clinical phenotypes, with some individuals with periodontitis retaining otherwise eubiotic microbiomes enriched for low-abundance pathobionts, while some cases of health or mild disease had highly dysbiotic communities, suggesting distinct host susceptibility. Together, these findings define a population-scale ecological landscape of the subgingival microbiome, reveal divergent trajectories to periodontal dysbiosis, and highlight heterogeneity in the relationship between microbial community structure and clinical disease expression.

microbiology↗

bioRxiv2026

Rapid and largely reversible shifts in the canine fecal metabolome during dietary change

Diet can rapidly change the fecal metabolome, but less is known about recovery after the original diet is restored. We used untargeted UPLC-MS metabolomics to analyze 72 fecal samples from nine Pumi dogs during an owner-managed switch from dry food to raw food and back to dry food. Diet phase accounted for a large proportion of variation in both ionization modes. More than 13,000 LC-MS features changed at the first sampling point after the switch to raw food, with a similarly large response after return to dry food. Among features significant in both comparisons, more than 99% changed in opposite directions. At the final sampling point, no positive-mode (ESI+) features and only 13 negative-mode (ESI-) features differed from the second dry-food baseline under the same threshold. BARF-associated patterns persisted in analyses excluding individual dogs and in pedigree-adjusted candidate models, although individual feature effects depended on normalization. Putative metabolites from several biochemical classes differed in their response and recovery. The fecal metabolome therefore changed rapidly and returned largely toward baseline, with differences among dogs.

microbiology↗

bioRxiv2026

Taxonomic and functional concordance between full-length ONT 16S and ONT shotgun metagenomics in the canine gut microbiome

Background: Full-length Oxford Nanopore Technologies (ONT) 16S rRNA sequencing provides a scalable view of microbial community composition and can support phylogeny-based functional prediction, but it is not equivalent to shotgun metagenomics. We asked which biological conclusions are preserved when the same canine fecal specimens are profiled by full-length ONT 16S and ONT whole-genome shotgun (WGS) sequencing, and how their agreement depends on analytical scale, reference representation and classifier. Methods: Ninety-seven fecal specimens from 51 dogs were profiled with both assays from the same DNA extract. Functional profiles predicted from NanoASV/NanoPredict with PICRUSt2 were compared with WGS-supported KEGG Ortholog (KO) profiles generated by Kadath. Taxonomy was benchmarked in a source-genome-matched RefSeq universe and in a host-specific DogMAG universe using minitax and Kraken2. Agreement was evaluated at whole-profile, feature-abundance, detection, between-sample structure and biological-inference scales. Age-associated transfer was assessed with dog-aware continuous mixed models, grouped signed-score analyses and paired/dog-blocked PERMANOVA. Results: Functional whole-profile concordance was high: median within-sample CLR Spearman correlations ranged from 0.781 to 0.860 across developmental strata, while between-sample functional structure remained significant by Mantel (rho=0.543) and Procrustes (r=0.693; both p=0.001). Feature-wise transfer was substantially weaker (median KO-wise CLR Spearman=0.318). Continuous age-associated KO slopes showed substantial cross-assay concordance (Spearman=0.727; signed-score Spearman=0.753; direction agreement=77.9%), although 1,290/5,258 eligible KOs retained significant assay-by-age interactions. Taxonomically, exact genus/species abundance agreement was much lower than agreement in between-sample ecological structure. Host-specific DogMAG improved species-level median Spearman from 0.261 to 0.656 for minitax SpeciesEstimate and from 0.181 to 0.512 for Kraken2. The classifier effect was independent of reference choice: under both RefSeq and DogMAG, minitax yielded stronger 16S-WGS concordance than Kraken2, with all eight prespecified RefSeq paired genus/species endpoints and all 10 DogMAG primary paired endpoints significant after BH correction. The same ordering extended to developmental inference, with DogMAG genus/species age-slope concordance of 0.795/0.799 for SpeciesEstimate versus 0.693/0.702 for Kraken2. Taxonomic Aitchison PERMANOVA detected age-associated structure in every assay/reference/classifier/rank combination, whereas age-by-assay interactions were consistently significant but small (R2 approximately 1.1 to 2.2%). Stricter NanoASV identity thresholds removed substantial 16S abundance without improving species-level agreement. Conclusions: The extent of cross-assay agreement depends on the level of analysis. Full-length ONT 16S preserves broad functional organization, ecological structure and much of the direction of age-associated change, but exact fine-rank composition, individual-feature abundance and effect magnitude remain assay dependent. Host-specific reference representation substantially narrows the taxonomic gap, and classifier choice exerts an additional independent effect: within the same matched reference set, minitax consistently yields stronger 16S-WGS concordance than Kraken2 across abundance, detection, ecological-distance and developmental-inference endpoints. Full-length ONT 16S is therefore well suited to broad ecological screening and hypothesis generation, whereas WGS remains preferable when conclusions depend on quantitative fine-rank composition, directly supported gene content or precise feature-level effect estimates.

microbiology↗