A global pause generates nonselective response inhibition during selective stopping

Abstract

1Response inhibition is essential for terminating inappropriate actions. Selective response inhibition may be required when stopping part of a multicomponent action. However, a persistent response delay (stopping-interference effect) indicates nonselective response inhibition during selective stopping. This study aimed to elucidate whether nonselective response inhibition is the consequence of a global pause process during attentional capture or specific to a nonselective cancel process during selective stopping. We hypothesised that the stopping-interference effect would be larger in response to stop than ignore signals, owing to stronger nonselective response inhibition for explicit selective stopping. Twenty healthy human participants of either sex performed a bimanual anticipatory response inhibition paradigm with selective stop and ignore signals. Frontocentral and sensorimotor beta ({beta})-bursts were recorded with electroencephalography. Corticomotor excitability (CME) and short-interval intracortical inhibition (SICI) in primary motor cortex were recorded with transcranial magnetic stimulation. Behaviourally, responses in the non-signalled hand were delayed during selective ignore and stop trials. The response delay was largest during selective stop trials and indicated that the stopping-interference effect could not be attributed entirely to attentional capture. A stimulus-nonselective increase in frontocentral {beta}-bursts occurred during stop and ignore trials, whilst sensorimotor response inhibition was reflected in maintenance of {beta}-bursts and SICI relative to disinhibition observed during go trials. Signatures of response inhibition in the sensorimotor cortex contralateral to the responding hand were not associated with the magnitude of stopping-interference. Therefore, nonselective response inhibition during selective stopping results primarily from a nonselective pause process but does not entirely account for the stopping-interference effect. 2 Significance statementSelective stopping is a complex form of response inhibition where a person must execute and cancel part of an action at the same time. A stopping-interference effect exemplifies the complexity of selective stopping. The present study examined whether nonselective response inhibition during selective stopping results from a global pause during attentional capture or is specific to a deliberate cancel process. Behaviourally, the interference effect was larger during selective stop stimuli than selective ignore stimuli. However, neurophysiological signatures of nonselective response inhibition were elicited in response to both stop and ignore stimuli. These findings indicate that nonselective response inhibition during selective stopping results primarily from a nonselective pause process but does not entirely account for the stopping-interference effect.