bioRxiv Science⌕ Search
Home/Archive/bioRxiv

bioRxiv · 10.1101/2022.12.15.520667

A microbial community growth model for dynamic phenotype predictions

Freiburger, A. P.·Dewey, J. A.·Foflonker, F.·Babnigg, G.·Antonopoulos, D. A.·Henry, C. S.
View original source ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

1Microbial communities are increasingly recognized as key drivers in animal health, agricultural productivity, industrial operations, and ecological systems. The abundance of chemical interactions in these complex communities, however, can complicate or evade experimental studies, which hinders basic understanding and limits efforts to rationally design communities for applications in the aforementioned fields. Numerous computational approaches have been proposed to deduce these metabolic interactions - notably including flux balance analysis (FBA) and systems of ordinary differential equations (ODEs) - yet, these methods either fail to capture the dynamic phenotype expression of community members or lack the abstractions required to fit or explain the diverse experimental omics data that can be acquired today. We therefore developed a dynamic model (CommPhitting) that deduces phenotype abundances and growth kinetics for each community member, concurrent with metabolic concentrations, by coupling flux profiles for each phenotype with experimental growth and -omics data of the community. These data are captured as variables and coefficients within a mixed integer linear optimization problem (MILP) designed to represent the associated biological processes. This problem finds the globally optimized fit to all experimental data of a trial, thereby most accurately computing aspects of the community: (1) species and phenotype abundances over time; (2) a linearized growth kinetic constant for each phenotype; and (3) metabolite concentrations over time. We exemplify CommPhitting by applying it to study batch growth of an idealized two-member community of the model organisms (Escherichia coli and Pseudomonas flourescens) that exhibits cross-feeding in maltose media. Measurements of this community from our accompanying experimental studies - including total biomass, species biomass, and metabolite abundances over time - were parameterized into a CommPhitting simulation. The resultant kinetics constants and biomass proportions for each member phenotype would be difficult to ascertain experimentally, yet are important for understanding community responses to environmental perturbations and therefore engineering applications: e.g. for bioproduction. We believe that CommPhitting - which is generalized for a diversity of data types and formats, and is further available and amply documented as a Python API - will augment basic understanding of microbial communities and will accelerate the engineering of synthetic communities for diverse applications in medicine, agriculture, industry, and ecology.

Explore related subjects

systems biologyPreprint

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Freiburger, A. P., Dewey, J. A., Foflonker, F., Babnigg, G., Antonopoulos, D. A., Henry, C. S.. 2022-12-18. A microbial community growth model for dynamic phenotype predictions. https://doi.org/10.1101/2022.12.15.520667

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related preprints

bioRxiv2026

Low-fidelity simulator selection for multi-fidelity inference of epithelial vertex models

Vertex models link cell division, neighbour exchange, and intercellular forces to epithelial tissue form through parameters such as junctional line tension and perimeter contractility. Bayesian inference of these parameters from data quantifies their uncertainty, but for stochastic models of proliferating tissues it requires many costly simulations. Multi-fidelity simulation-based inference reduces this cost by training on many runs of a cheaper, less accurate ('low-fidelity') simulator before refining with a few full ('high-fidelity') runs. Low-fidelity versions can be constructed in several ways, for example by stopping simulations early, coarsening the timestep, or averaging fewer replicates, but it is unclear which to choose before committing to costly training. To address this, we introduce PRISM (Paired Ranking Index for Simulator Matching), a screen that compares each candidate with the full simulator on paired runs, scoring agreement in cell-packing statistics against cost. For a vertex model of a proliferating tissue, PRISM flags stopping early as unreliable before training; once trained, this choice can produce confidently wrong parameter estimates. By contrast, a coarser timestep, within the range tested, is cheap and accurate; while fewer replicates are accurate but too costly. Using a screened low-fidelity simulator, multi-fidelity inference outperforms approximate Bayesian computation and neural-network inference trained on full simulations alone, at matched cost and with well-calibrated uncertainty. The same pattern recurs for a second vertex model fitted to published Drosophila pupal-wing imaging data, although there stopping halfway proves safe. Together, our findings suggest that which approximations are safe depends on the model, and that screening them before training makes multi-fidelity inference of tissue mechanics practical.

systems biology↗
bioRxiv2026

Calibrating developmental dynamics from single-cell atlases: lineage paths outrun least-action routes

Single-cell atlases infer developmental dynamics from destructive snapshots, yet how far realized lineage paths depart from such inferred dynamics has never been measured with controls. We introduce LADD (Least-Action Developmental Dynamics), a measurement framework that learns a stochastic developmental vector field from time-series single-cell RNA-seq and computes minimum-action and minimum-time paths, together with a three-layer calibration protocol that separates genuine path deviation from the generic cost of centroid measurement, and we compare its forecasting component with optimal-transport and flow-matching methods. In the lineage-resolved Caenorhabditis elegans atlas, the raw action ratio of observed lineage-centroid trajectories to optimal paths is 3.79, yet forward-simulated ensembles of the learned model itself score 2.07, leaving a genuine excess of about two-fold. In zebrafish (Danio rerio), the observed ratio sits entirely at the model's floor. Three mechanisms that could explain the residual deviation (detours, flow-opposition, and fate-map complexity) are each excluded; what remains is speed, with lineages moving 30-43% faster along the learned flow. We report validity boundaries for temporal resolution, cross-species comparison, and energetic interpretation, delimiting where action-based trajectory comparisons are meaningful.

systems biology↗
bioRxiv2026

Choice of annotation data significantly impacts automated reconstruction of genome-scale metabolic networks

Genome-scale metabolic models are valuable tools for studying metabolism in many applications, such as metabolic engineering or understanding human disease. However, curated models are available for only a limited number of organisms, and generating high-quality models for additional organisms remains a challenge. To help address this challenge, several software tools have been developed that can produce draft models in an automated fashion, but the quality of these draft models lags behind manually curated ones. Thus, there is still a need to improve these tools. Previous work has focused primarily on developing better methods for each step in the reconstruction process, such as gene annotation and gap-filling. Here, we focus on the data that underlies these methods, such as known connections between protein sequence and function. We find that changing the source of reconstruction data has a substantial impact on the contents and predictions of generated models. In fact, the source of data can have a bigger impact than the choice of reconstruction method. Additionally, we show that the reconstruction process is sensitive to the accuracy of gene annotations in the reconstruction data. Finally, we demonstrate the importance of having functional annotation data from an organism that is closely related to the one for which a model is being built. These observations highlight the importance of reconstruction data and identify principles that should be considered when selecting data for reconstruction tools.

systems biology↗