ATG9 vesicles comprise the seed membrane of mammalian autophagosomes

Abstract

During autophagosome biogenesis, the incorporation of transmembrane proteins into the expanding phagophore is not readily observed. In addition, the membrane surface area of the organelle expands rapidly, while the volume of the autophagosome is kept low. Several recent studies have suggested a model of membrane expansion that explains how these attributes are maintained. The autophagosome expands predominantly through the direct protein-mediated transfer of lipids through the lipid transfer protein ATG2. As these lipids are only introduced into the cytoplasmic-facing leaflet of the expanding phagophore, full membrane growth also requires lipid scramblase activity. ATG9 has been demonstrated to harbor scramblase activity and is essential to autophagosome formation, however if and when it is integrated into mammalian autophagosomes remains unclear. Here we show that in the absence of lipid transport, ATG9 vesicles are already fully competent to collect proteins normally found on mature autophagosomes, including LC3-II. Further, through the novel use of styrene-maleic acid lipid particles as a nanoscale interrogation of protein organization on intact membranes, we show that ATG9 is fully integrated in the same membranes as LC3-II, even on maturing autophagosomes. The ratios of these two proteins at different stages of maturation demonstrate that ATG9 proteins are not continuously integrated, but rather are present on the seed vesicles only and become diluted in the rapidly expanding autophagosome membrane. Thus, ATG9 vesicles are the seed membrane from which mammalian autophagosomes form.