Integration of metabolism and regulation reveals rapid adaptability to growth on non-native substrates.

Abstract

Engineering synthetic heterotrophy (i.e., growth on non-native substrates) is key to the efficient bio-based valorization of renewable and waste substrates. Among these, engineering hemicellulosic pentose utilization has been well-explored in Saccharomyces cerevisiae (yeast) over several decades - yet the answer to what makes their utilization inherently recalcitrant remains elusive. Through implementation of a semi-synthetic regulon, we find that harmonizing cellular and engineering objectives are key to obtaining highest growth rates and yields with minimal metabolic engineering effort. Concurrently, results indicate that "extrinsic" factors - specifically, upstream genes that direct flux of pentoses into central carbon metabolism - are rate-limiting. We also reveal that yeast metabolism is innately highly adaptable to rapid growth on non-native substrates and that systems metabolic engineering (i.e., flux balancing, directed evolution, functional genomics, and network modeling) is largely unnecessary. We posit that the need for extensive engineering espoused by prior works is a consequence of unfortunate (albeit avoidable) antagonism between engineering and cellular objectives. We also found that deletion of endogenous genes to promote growth demonstrate inconsistent outcomes that are genetic-context- and condition-dependent. For the most part, these knockouts also lead to deleterious pleiotropic effects that decrease the robustness of strains against inhibitors and stressors associated with bioprocessing. Thus, at best, perturbation of "intrinsic" factors (e.g., native metabolic, regulatory genes) results in incremental and inconsistent benefits. At worst, they are detrimental. Overall, this work provides insight into the limitations and pitfalls to realizing efficient synthetic heterotrophy using traditional/systems metabolic engineering approaches, demonstrates the innate adaptability of yeast for metabolism of non-native substrates, and provides an alternate, novel, holistic (and yet minimalistic) approach based on integrating non-native metabolic genes with a native regulon system.