Dynamic utilization of low-molecular-weight organic substrates across a microbial growth rate gradient

Abstract

Constantly in flux, low-molecular-weight organic substances (LMWOSs) are at the nexus between microorganisms, plant roots, detritus, and the soil mineral matrix. Nominal oxidation state of carbon (NOSC) has been put forward as one way to parameterize microbial uptake rates of LMWOSs and efficiency of carbon incorporation into new biomass. In this study, we employed an ecophysiological approach to test these proposed relationships using targeted exometabolomics (1H-NMR, HR-LCMS) coupled with stable isotope (13C) probing. We assessed the role of compound class and oxidation state on uptake kinetics and substrate-specific carbon use efficiency (SUE) during the growth of three model soil microorganisms (Penicillium spinulosum, Paraburkholderia solitsugae, and Ralstonia pickettii) in media containing 34 common LMWOSs. Microbial isolates were chosen to span a gradient in growth rate (0.046-0.316 hr-1) and differ phylogenetically (a fungal isolate and two bacterial isolates). Clustered, co-utilization of LMWOSs occured for all three organisms, but temporal cluster separation was most apparent for P. solitsugae. Potential trends (p <0.05) for early utilization of more oxidized substrates were present for the two bacterial isolates (P. solitsugae and R. pickettii), but high variability (R2 > 0.15) and a small effect of NOSC indicate these are not useful relationships for prediction. The SUEs ranged from 0.16-0.99 and the hypothesized inverse relationship between NOSC and SUE was not observed. Thus, our results do not provide compelling support for NOSC as a predictive tool, implying that metabolic strategies of organisms may be more important than chemical identity in determining LMWOS cycling in soils. ImportanceCommunity-level observations from soils indicate that low-molecular-weight compounds of higher oxidation state tend to be depleted from soil solution faster and incorporated less efficiently into microbial biomass under oxic conditions. Here, we tested hypothetical relationships between substrate chemical characteristics and the order of substrate utilization by aerobic heterotrophs at the population-level in culture, using two bacterial isolates (Ralstonia pickettii and Paraburkholderia solitsugae) and one fungal isolate from soil (Penicillium spinulosum). We found weak relationships indicating earlier uptake of more oxidized substrates by the two bacterial isolates but no relationship for the fungal isolate. We found no relationship between substrate identity and substrate use efficiency. Our findings indicate that substrate chemical characteristics have limited utility for modeling the depletion of low-molecular-weight organics from soil solution and incorporation into biomass over broader phylogenetic gradients.