Testing for association with rare variants in the coding and non-coding genome: RAVA-FIRST, a new approach based on CADD deleteriousness score

Abstract

Rare variant association tests (RVAT) have been developed to study the contribution of rare variants widely accessible through high-throughput sequencing technologies. RVAT require to aggregate rare variants in testing units and to filter variants to retain only the most likely causal ones. In the exome, genes are natural testing units and variants are usually filtered based on their functional consequences. However, when dealing with whole-genome sequence (WGS) data, both steps are challenging. No natural biological unit is available for aggregating rare variants. Sliding windows procedures have been proposed to circumvent this difficulty, however they are blind to biological information and result in a large number of tests. We propose a new strategy to perform RVAT on WGS data: "RAVA-FIRST" (RAre Variant Association using Functionally-InfoRmed STeps) comprising three steps. (1) New testing units are defined genome-wide based on functionally-adjusted Combined Annotation Dependent Depletion (CADD) scores of variants observed in the GnomAD populations, which are referred to as "CADD regions". (2) A region-dependent filtering of rare variants is applied in each CADD region. (3) A functionally-informed burden test is performed with sub-scores computed for each genomic category within each CADD region. Both on simulations and real data, RAVA-FIRST was found to outperform other WGS-based RVAT. Applied to a WGS dataset of venous thromboembolism patients, we identified an intergenic region on chromosome 18 that is enriched for rare variants in early-onset patients and that was that was missed by standard sliding windows procedures. RAVA-FIRST enables new investigations of rare non-coding variants in complex diseases, facilitated by its implementation in the R package Ravages. Author SummaryTechnological progresses have made possible whole genome sequencing at an unprecedented scale, opening up the possibility to explore the role of genetic variants of low frequency in common diseases. The challenge is now methodological and requires the development of novel methods and strategies to analyse sequencing data that are not limited to assessing the role of coding variants. With RAVA-FIRST, we propose a novel strategy to investigate the role of rare variants in the whole-genome that takes benefit from biological information. Especially, RAVA-FIRST relies on testing units that go beyond genes to gather rare variants in the association tests. In this work, we show that this new strategy presents several advantages compared to existing methods. RAVA-FIRST offers an easy and straightforward analysis of genome-wide rare variants, especially the intergenic ones which are frequently left behind, making it a promising tool to get a better understanding of the biology of complex diseases.