Does genetic differentiation underlie behavioral divergence in response tomigration barriers in sticklebacks? A common garden experiment

Abstract

Water management measures in the 1970s in the Netherlands have produced a large number of resident populations of three-spined sticklebacks that are no longer able to migrate to the sea. This may be viewed as a replicated field experiment, allowing us to study how the resident populations are coping with human-induced barriers to migration. We have previously shown that residents are smaller, bolder, more exploratory, more active, more aggressive, exhibited lower shoaling and lower migratory tendencies compared to their ancestral migrant counterparts. However, it is not clear if these differences in wild-caught residents and migrants reflect genetic differentiation, rather than different developmental conditions. To investigate this, we raised offspring of four crosses (migrant [male] x migrant [female], resident [male] x resident [female], migrant [male] x resident [female], resident [male] x migrant [female]) under similar controlled conditions and tested for differences in morphology and behavior as adults. We found that lab-raised resident sticklebacks exhibited lower shoaling and migratory tendencies as compared to lab-raised migrants, retaining the differences in their wild-caught parents. This indicates genetic differentiation of these traits. For all other traits, the lab-raised sticklebacks of the various crosses did not differ significantly, suggesting that the earlier-found contrast between wild-caught fish reflect differences in their environment. Our study shows that barriers to migration can lead to rapid differentiation in behavioral tendencies over contemporary timescales ([~]50 generations), and that part of these differences reflects genetic differentiation. Significance statementMany organisms face changes to their habitats due to human activities. Much research is therefore dedicated to the question whether and how organisms are able to adapt to novel conditions. We address this question in three-spined sticklebacks, where water management measures cut off some populations, prohibiting their seasonal migration to the North Sea. In a previous study, we showed that wild-caught resident fish exhibited markedly different behavior than migrants. To disentangle whether these differences reflect genetic differentiation or differences in the conditions under which the wild-caught fish grew up, we conducted crosses, raising the F1 offspring under identical conditions. As their wild-caught parents, the F1 of resident x resident crosses exhibited lower migratory and shoaling tendencies than the F1 of migrant x migrant crosses, while the F1 of hybrid crosses were intermediate. This suggests that [~]50 years of isolation are sufficient to induce behaviorally relevant genetic differentiation.