BMP signaling underlies the craniofacial heterochrony in phyllostomid bats, a hyperdiverse mammal group

Abstract

The potential for variation and the capacity to evolve in response to ecological opportunity are important aspects of an adaptive radiation. Identifying the origin of phenotypic variation, in which natural selection might act upon, is a major goal of evolutionary developmental biology. The New World leaf-nosed bats (phyllostomids) are a textbook example of an adaptive radiation. Their cranial morphology is diverse along relative facial length, which is related to their diets. We previously used geometric morphometrics to reveal peramorphosis, a type of heterochrony, in the cranial evolution among phyllostomid bats. We then demonstrated that the mechanism of peramorphic diversity in phyllostomid rostrum length resulted from altered cellular proliferation. Here, we investigate the progenitors of the face, the cranial neural crest, and a key signaling pathway related to their proliferation and differentiation into mature tissues: the bone morphogenetic protein (BMP). With geometric morphometrics, immunofluorescence, and confocal imaging--in three phyllostomid species and one outgroup bat species--we show the molecular patterns that underlie the adaptive and innovative traits seen in phyllostomid bats. Then, with mouse genetics, we mimic the BMP molecular pattern observed in nectar feeding bats and recapitulate the elongated morphological variation in mice. Surprisingly, we also observe an expansion in the nose-tip of mice, akin to the expanding leaf-nose tissue in phyllostomid bats. These data, combined with the mouse genetics literature on BMP signaling, suggest the BMP developmental pathway plays a central role in shaping the craniofacial variation necessary for adaptation in bats. Further, we speculate that the BMP signaling pathway could underlie other bizarre facial phenotypes in mammals that are derived from frontonasal mesenchyme, such as the proboscis. Overall, this study combines a comparative framework to developmental data, with a genetic approach, to directly investigate the role of development on complex morphology.