Instructor-learner neural synchronization during elaborated feedback predicts learning transfer

Abstract

The provision of feedback with complex information beyond the correct answer, i.e., elaborated feedback, can powerfully shape learning outcomes such as transfer, i.e., the ability to extend what has been learned in one context to new contexts. However, an understanding of neurocognitive processes of elaborated feedback during instructor-learner interactions remains elusive. Here, a two-person interactive design is used during simultaneous recording of functional near-infrared spectroscopy (fNIRS) signals from adult instructor-learner dyads. Instructors either provided elaborated feedback (i.e., correct answer and an example) or simple feedback (i.e., correct answer only) to learners during a concept learning task. Our results showed that elaborated feedback produced comparable levels of retention to simple feedback, however, transfer was significantly enhanced by elaboration. We also noted significant instructor-learner neural synchronization in frontoparietal regions during the provision of elaborated feedback, especially when examples were provided. Further, interpersonal neural synchronization in the parietal cortex successfully predicted transfer of knowledge to novel contexts. This prediction was retained for both learner-delayed and learner-preceding neural synchronization. These findings point toward transfer effects of elaborated feedback provided in a social context can be predictable through interpersonal neural synchronization, which may hold important implications for real-world learning and pedagogical efficacy. Educational Impact and Implications StatementFeedback provides learners with crucial information regarding the gap between what has currently been achieved and what remains to be achieved, and thus plays a critical role in any learning process. In real-world settings, feedback is typically provided and received through social interaction, and high-quality "elaborated feedback" contains complex information that goes beyond the correct answer. This study aims to elucidate the neurocognitive processes underpinning elaborated feedback during instructor-learner interactions. We detected significant instructor-learner neural synchronization in mutual frontoparietal brain regions during elaborated feedback, particularly during the provision of specific elaborated information (i.e., concrete examples). Moreover, this synchronization (including learner-delayed and learner-preceded synchronization) in the parietal region predicted whether the learners transferred learning to novel examples of learned psychology concepts. This study advances current understanding on the neural mechanisms for elaborated feedback and the role of social interaction in feedback effects. These results may have important implications for successful real-world learning and communication, and related pedagogical applications in educational settings.