Detecting unreported recalls in memory experiments

Abstract

In experiments on free recall from lists of items, not all memory retrievals are necessarily reported. Previous studies investigated unreported retrievals by attempting to induce their externalization. We show that, without any intervention, their statistics may be directly estimated through a model-free analysis of inter-response times - the silent intervals between recalls. A delay attributable to unreported recalls emerges in three situations: if the final item was already recalled ("silent recency effect"); if the item that, within the list, follows the latest recalled item was already recalled ("silent contiguity effect"); and in sequential recalls within highly performing trials ("sequential slowdown"). We then turn to reproducing all these effects by a minimal model where the discarding of memories ("bouncing") occurs either if they are repetitious or, in strategically organized trials, if they are not sequential. Based on our findings, we propose various approaches to further probing the submerged dynamics of memory retrieval.