Remodeling hydrogen bond interactions results in relaxed specificity of Caspase-3

Abstract

Caspase enzymes play important roles in apoptosis and inflammation, and the non-identical but overlapping specificity profiles direct cells to different fates. Although all caspases prefer aspartate at the P1 position of the substrate, the caspase-6 subfamily shows preference for valine at the P4 position, while caspase-3 shows preference for aspartate. In comparison to human caspases, caspase-3a from zebrafish has relaxed specificity and demonstrates equal selection for either valine or aspartate at the P4 position. In the context of the caspase-3 conformational landscape, we show that changes in hydrogen bonding near the S3 subsite affect selection of the P4 amino acid. Swapping specificity with caspase-6 requires accessing new conformational space, where each landscape results in optimal binding of DxxD (caspase-3) or VxxD (caspase-6) substrate and simultaneously disfavors binding of the other substrate. Within the context of the caspase-3 conformational landscape, substitutions near the active site result in nearly equal activity against DxxD and VxxD by disrupting a hydrogen bonding network in the substrate binding pocket. The converse substitutions in zebrafish caspase-3a result in increased selection for P4 aspartate over valine. Overall, the data show that evolutionary neofunctionalization resulting in a dual function protease, as in zebrafish caspase-3a, requires fewer amino acid substitutions compared to those required to access new conformational space for swapping substrate specificity, such as between caspases-3 and -6.