Mechanistic Analysis of the Broad Antiretroviral Resistance Conferred by HIV-1 Envelope Glycoprotein Mutations

Abstract

Despite the effectiveness of antiretroviral (ARV) therapy, virological failure can occur in some HIV-1 infected patients in the absence of mutations in the proteins targeted by these drugs. We previously reported that, in vitro, the lab-adapted NL4-3 strain of HIV-1 can acquire resistance to the integrase inhibitor dolutegravir (DTG) by acquiring mutations in the envelope glycoprotein (Env) that enhance the ability of HIV-1 to spread via cell-cell transmission. In this study, we investigated whether Env-mediated drug resistance extends to ARVs other than DTG and whether it occurs in other HIV-1 isolates. We demonstrate that Env mutations can broadly confer resistance to multiple classes of ARVs in the context of cell-cell but not cell-free infection and also increase resistance to ARVs when coupled with target-gene drug resistance mutations. To investigate the mechanism of Env-mediated drug resistance, we evaluated the impact of the Env mutations on Env stability and conformational dynamics. We observe that the NL4-3 Env mutants display a more stable and closed Env conformation compared to WT virus and reduced rates of gp120 shedding. We also selected for mutations in the gp41 ectodomain of clinically relevant, CCR5-tropic isolates in the presence of DTG. These Env mutants exhibit reduced susceptibility to DTG, with effects on replication kinetics and Env structure that are HIV-1 strain-dependent. Finally, to examine a possible in vivo relevance of Env-mediated drug resistance, we performed single-genome sequencing of plasma-derived virus from five patients failing an integrase inhibitor-containing regimen. This analysis revealed the presence of several mutations in the highly conserved gp120-gp41 interface despite low frequency of resistance mutations in integrase. These results suggest a "stepping-stone" model whereby mutations in Env that enhance the ability of HIV-1 to spread via a cell-cell route increase the opportunity for the virus to acquire high-level drug resistance mutations in ARV-target genes. Author summaryAlthough combination antiretroviral (ARV) therapy has proven highly effective in controlling the progression of HIV disease, drug resistance can be a major obstacle to long-term treatment, particularly in resource-limited settings. In most cases, resistance arises from the accumulation of mutations in the ARV-target genes; however, in some cases, resistance develops without ARV target-gene mutations. We previously reported that mutations in the HIV-1 envelope glycoprotein (Env) confer resistance to an integrase inhibitor. Here we investigated the mechanism of Env-mediated drug resistance and the possible contribution of Env to virological failure in vivo. We demonstrate that Env mutations can confer broad resistance to multiple classes of ARVs and define the effect of the Env mutations on Env subunit interactions and sensitivity to neutralizing antibodies. We also selected for drug resistance mutations in Env in clinically relevant HIV-1 isolates. We observed that many Env mutations accumulated in individuals failing integrase inhibitor therapy despite a low frequency of resistance mutations in integrase. Our findings suggest that broad-based, Env-mediated drug resistance may impact current and possibly future therapeutic strategies. Our findings also provide clues towards understanding how ARV-treated patients can experience virological failure without acquiring drug resistance mutations in ARV-target genes.