Production of diverse beauveriolide analogs in closely related fungi: a rare case of fungal chemodiversity

Abstract

Fungal chemodiversity is well known in part due to the production of diverse analogous compounds by a single biosynthetic gene cluster (BGCs). Usually, similar metabolites are produced by closely related fungal species. Here we report a rare case of the production of the cyclodepsipeptide beauveriolides (BVDs) in three insect pathogenic fungi. We found that the more closely-related fungi Beauveria bassiana and B. brongniartii produce structurally distinct analogs of BVDs whereas the rather divergently evolved species B. brongniartii and Cordyceps militaris produce structural analogs in a similar pattern. It was verified that a conserved BGC containing four genes is responsible for BVD biosynthesis in three fungi including a polyketide synthase (PKS) for the production of 3-hydroxy fatty acids (FAs) with chain length variations. In contrast to BVD production patterns, phylogenetic analysis of the BGC enzymes or enzyme domains largely resulted in the congruence relationship with fungal speciation. Feeding assays demonstrated that a FA with a chain length of eight carbon atoms was preferentially utilized whereas a FA with a chain longer than 10 carbon atoms could not be used as a substrate for BVD biosynthesis. We also found that addition of D-type amino acids could not enable B. bassiana to produce those analogs biosynthesized by other two fungi. Insect survival assays suggested that the contribution of BVD to fungal virulence might be associated with the susceptibility of insect species. The results of this study enrich the knowledge of fungal secondary metabolic diversity. IMPORTANCEFungal chemotaxonomy is an approach to classify fungi based on fungal production of natural compounds especially the secondary metabolites. We found an atypical example that could question chemical classification of fungi in this study: the more closely-related entomopathogenic species Beauveria bassiana and B. brongniartii produce structurally different analogs of the cyclodepsipeptide beauveriolides whereas the rather divergent species B. brongniartii and Cordyceps militaris biosynthesize similar analogs under the same growth condition. The conserved BGC containing four genes is present in each species and responsible for beauveriolide production. In contrast to the compound formation profiles, the phylogenies of biosynthetic enzymes or enzymatic domains show associations with fungal speciation relationship. Dependent on insect species, production of beauveriolides may contribute to fungal virulence against insect. The findings in this study augment the diversity of fungal secondary metabolisms.