Hunting for Helminths: short- and long-read shotgun metagenomics for parasite detection in faecal samples
Soil-transmitted helminths (STHs) pose significant challenges to public health in endemic areas, necessitating reliable methods for their detection. Shotgun metagenomics enables simultaneous detection of STHs and microbes in a sample without prior knowledge of what is present. However, validation of shotgun metagenomics with known infection intensity or across different sequencing platforms has not been carried out for eukaryote parasites including STHs, and false positives remain a pervasive issue. We validated shotgun metagenomics as a method of STH detection in faecal samples. Using the Strongyloides ratti laboratory model of a STH infection we investigated how analytical methods (nucleotide-nucleotide matching, nucleotide-protein matching, marker gene detection, mitochondrial mapping), infection intensity and sequencing technology (short-read vs. long-read) affects sensitivity and specificity of detection. S. ratti was accurately detected at a standard laboratory dose, but low intensity infections were more difficult to detect. Only mitochondrial sequence mapping was 100% accurate at identifying S. ratti with no false positives. Overall, short-read outperformed long-read sequencing methods. We applied the same analytical methods to human faecal samples with confirmed infections for at least one of four STHs. Mitochondrial sequence mapping was also the most effective method for detecting STHs in human faecal samples, detecting 100% of Necator americanus and 92% of Ascaris spp. infections, but could not reliably detect STHs where DNA levels are expected to be low or variable. In conclusion, mitochondrial mapping was the most effective method of detection for sensitivity and specificity in both the laboratory system and human faecal samples. Our findings indicate that shotgun metagenomics should be approached cautiously using validated methods, particularly when infection intensity or DNA levels are expected to be low. Author SummarySoil-transmitted helminths (STH) such as the parasite Strongyloides, are important gastrointestinal parasites of humans and livestock. Accurate methods of detection for diagnostics and monitoring are important to implement suitable control and treatment strategies. Here we validate a shotgun metagenomics approach, where all DNA in a sample is sequenced, for detecting STH in faecal samples using a Strongyloides laboratory model for infection. Strongyloides was reliability detected in faecal samples at higher infection levels, but mitochondrial genome mapping of the sequences was the only analytical method that reliably detected Strongyloides at lower infections levels. These results were reflected in stool samples from humans infected with STH, where mitochondrial mapping was also the most reliable method. However, species that were associated with low levels of parasite material or DNA in the faeces including Strongyloides stercoralis, were more difficult to detect. We compared two sequencing methods: short-read Illumina and long-read Oxford Nanopore Technologies, but short-read outperformed long-read shotgun metagenomics. Contamination of bacteria sequences in parasite genome assemblies was problematic for analysis and contributed to false positive results. Future work should focus on specific targeting of eukaryote DNA either at the laboratory or bioinformatic stage to improve STH detection further.