Biology subjects

Willmott, K.

Publications and source records attributed to Willmott, K..

4 recordsLinked to original sources

bioRxiv2025

Müllerian mimicry in Neotropical butterflies: One mimicry ring to bring them all, and in the jungle bind them

Understanding the mechanisms underlying species distributions and coexistence is essential to predict and prevent the impacts of global change, particularly in biodiversity hotspots. However, the effects of biotic interactions may be challenging to investigate at large spatial scales. Leveraging well-characterized Mullerian mimetic systems in Neotropical butterflies, we investigated spatial patterns of mutualistic mimetic interactions within and between two tribes of aposematic Nymphalid butterflies: the Heliconiini (Heliconiinae) and the Ithomiini (Danainae). Despite 85 My of independent evolutionary histories, many species share similar warning wing patterns across the Neotropics. In this study we show that both tribes form similar biodiversity hotspots with a high prevalence of rare species and mimetic patterns in the tropical Andes. However, we reveal a higher relative richness of heliconiine butterflies than ithomiines in the Amazon basin contrasting with the Andean concentration of ithomiine diversity. Despite this difference in broadscale diversity patterns, we also document large-scale spatial associations among phenotypically similar species within and between tribes, thereby providing new empirical evidence for Fritz Mullers historical model of mutualistic mimicry at a continental scale. Furthermore, comparative phylogenetic analyses suggest that co-mimetic species within and between tribes have converged towards similar climatic niches as a response to selection favoring co-occurrence. Our findings illustrate the strength of mutualistic interactions in shaping biodiversity patterns at continental scale and in supporting niche convergence even across millions of years of evolution. Critically, it also emphasizes the pervasive vulnerability of mimetic communities, bound by positive interactions, to disassembly induced by climate change. Significance statementMullerian mimicry is a remarkable example of convergent evolution driven by natural selection where coexisting prey species converge in their warning signal advertising their defenses to predators. Heliconiine and ithomiine butterflies found throughout Neotropical rainforests were instrumental in Fritz Mullers historical model, which provided the mechanism for such resemblance. Leveraging decades of fieldwork and museum collections, we show that species with similar color patterns present strikingly similar spatial distributions, regardless of how closely related they are. Such co-occurrence appears reinforced by the evolution of similar climatic requirements among look-alike species. Our findings emphasize the key role of mutualistic interactions in shaping large-scale patterns of biodiversity and supporting convergence in the climatic niches of species spanning across phylogenetically distant clades.

evolutionary biology↗

bioRxiv2021

Standardized nuclear markers advance metazoan taxonomy

Species are the fundamental units of life and their recognition is essential for science and society. DNA barcoding, the use of a single and often mitochondrial gene, has been increasingly employed as a universal approach for the identification of animal species. However, this approach faces several challenges. Here, we demonstrate with empirical data from a number of metazoan animal lineages that multiple nuclear-encoded markers, so called universal single-copy orthologs (USCOs) performs much better than the single barcode gene to discriminate closely related species. Overcoming the general shortcomings of mitochondrial DNA barcodes, USCOs also accurately assign samples to higher taxonomic levels. These loci thus provide a powerful and unifying framework for species delimitation which considerably improves the DNA-based inference of animal species.

molecular biology↗

bioRxiv2019

Rainfall As A Significant Contributing Factor To Butterfly Seasonality Along A Climatic Gradient In The Neotropics

We analyzed the dynamics of multi-species butterfly communities along a climatic gradient with varying precipitation regimes for three consecutive years, and determine how climatic variables associate with observed butterfly seasonality. To provide a baseline for future studies of how climate change might affect these butterfly populations, we additionally explored the role of butterfly seasonality as a potential contributing factor for their susceptibility to climate variation. As far as we know, this represents the first study that simultaneously sampled and described seasonality patterns of tropical butterfly communities across ecosystems with varying climatic seasonality. A 3-year survey was carried out at three sites (i.e., wet, transition and dry forests) across a climatic gradient in western Ecuador. Butterflies were sampled using traps baited with rotting banana and prawn every two months from Nov 2010 to Sep 2013. Traps were set up at two heights, in the understory and canopy. In total, 7046 individuals of 212 species were sampled over 180 sampling days.\n\nButterfly communities exhibited conspicuous intra and inter-annual variation in temporal dynamics with certain elements (e.g., maximum abundance recorded) of seasonality patterns likely synchronized in seasonal forests (i.e., transition and dry forest) across years but not in aseasonal forests (i.e., wet forest). In addition, the highest numbers of species and individuals occurred during the wet season across all study sites and years; indeed, rainfall was significantly positively associated with temporal abundance. Likewise, butterfly species displaying stronger seasonality were significantly associated with higher rainfall periods in seasonal forests. Variation in precipitation regimes might significantly affect more seasonal species.

ecology↗

bioRxiv2019

ASSEMBLY MECHANISMS OF NEOTROPICAL BUTTERFLY COMMUNITIES ALONG AN ENVIRONMENTAL GRADIENT

Our goal was to test the hypothesis that assembly processes that limit species similarity (i.e., competition) predominantly occur in more stable abiotic environments, whereas habitat filtering (i.e., habitat characteristics) is a major driver of community composition within more variable environments at regional (e.g., aseasonal vs seasonal forests) and local scales (e.g., understory vs. canopy). A combined approach of phylogenetic- and functional trait-based analyses using forewing length and aspect ratio as traits, were used to this hypothesis.\n\nA 3-year survey was carried out at three sites (i.e., wet, transition and dry forests) across a climatic gradient in western Ecuador. Transition and dry forests were considered as seasonal, whereas wet forest were considered aseasonal. Butterflies were sampled using traps baited with rotting banana and prawn every two months from Nov 2010 to Sep 2013. Traps were set up at two heights, in the understory and canopy. DNA was extracted to sequence the barcode section of the mitochondrial gene cytochrome oxidase 1 (COI) for phylogenetic analyses. Measurements of morphological traits, forewing length and aspect ratio were done using digital photographs of specimens.\n\nA total of 6466 specimens representing 142 species of Nymphalidae were recorded. Based on phylogenetic- and trait-based analyses, we rejected the hypothesis that assembly processes that limit species similarity (i.e., competition) are likely to predominantly occur in more stable abiotic environments, whereas habitat filtering can be a major driver of community composition within more variable environments at regional (i.e., aseasonal forest vs seasonal forests) and local scales (i.e., understory vs. canopy). My study of assembly mechanisms revealed the opposite pattern, with stronger evidence for the action of ecological filters in the assembly of butterfly communities from the wet aseasonal forests, and competition likely to be a major assembly process within dry seasonal forests. The present study therefore provided new insights into community assembly mechanisms in one of the richest butterfly faunas worldwide.

ecology↗