bioRxiv Science⌕ Search

Biology subjects

Westoby, M.

Publications and source records attributed to Westoby, M..

7 recordsLinked to original sources

Nutrient currencies and P resorption greatly amplify the perceived costs of reproductive allocation in perennial heath shrubs

SummaryO_LIIn woody perennials, reproductive allocation considered as a fraction of NPP (RA) has been rarely quantified, especially tracked across plant lifetimes, measured in biologically meaningful currencies, and separated from standing biomass. C_LIO_LIWe addressed this gap by measuring dry mass, nitrogen, and phosphorus for every aboveground tissue type for 14 iteroparous perennial shrubs tracked across their full lifetimes, calculating RA using four accounting schemes and three currencies. C_LIO_LIRA was substantially higher by mid-life than typical estimates from ecosystem-scale studies. Distinguishing standing biomass from yearly production further revised RA upwards. Using a nutrient currency (especially P) increased the perceived costs of reproduction. Propagules were highly nutrient-enriched and reproductive accessory costs consumed more nutrients than did the propagules themselves. Considering N and P resorption from senescing leaves and wood shrank the effective vegetative nutrient budget, further concentrating net annual nutrient demand in reproductive tissues. C_LIO_LIOur results highlight high investment in RA for woody perennials, especially using nutrient currencies. Broadly similar allocation patterns were observed across species with different functional traits and lifespans, suggesting generality that may apply across biomes. Widespread underestimation of RA in forest growth models likely overestimates the proportion of NPP available for vegetative growth, leading to substantial errors in predictions. C_LI

ecology↗

A general framework explaining variation in plant economics traits with environment and through ontogeny

Plant economics traits, such as leaf mass per unit leaf area (LMA) and stem specific density (SSD), capture diversity among plant species in how common tissues (leaf, wood, root) are constructed. These traits are key descriptors of plant strategy, yet it has proven difficult to explain this variation with theory and process-based models. Here we reveal a general explanation on why these economics traits vary with environment, through ontogeny, and with other plant traits. This explanation relies on three core assumptions: 1) plants seek to maximise growth rate, 2) growth rate can be decomposed into a product, and 3) there is a tradeoff between the efficiency of tissue construction and tissue turnover rate. Formulation of growth as a product is essential, as it causes the optimal value of an economics trait to vary with the plants biomass production rate, which means economics traits will naturally covary with the abiotic environment, the competitive context, and other strategical features of the plant. Finally, we show how a modification of the trait into plastic and non-plastic components alters the magnitude of intra-specific responses, aligning model responses with empirical trends. Broadly, our results help explain how plant form and function for a wide diversity of species is shaped to suit their environment and, moreover, they reveal insight into a general fast-slow spectrum (Reich 2014) with coordinated shifts among organs (leaf & stem) through tradeoffs between efficient tissue construction and turnover.

ecology↗

The most abundant plant species of Eastern Australia and our knowledge of their traits

O_LIThe rule that most species are relatively rare and few are common has been of central importance to many branches of ecology. This rule also implies that just a few species make up the majority of plant biomass in ecosystems. Focussing plant trait research on the most common species in a region could be useful for many applications, including understanding macroscale patterns of species assemblages at the continental scale, identifying strategies of abundant species or estimating landscape-scale fluxes of carbon and water. C_LIO_LIHere, we rank species based on their total cover across an entire continental region-- Eastern and Central Australia--and report the extent of trait coverage in terms of vegetation cover. To calculate species abundance and trait coverage, we used [~]100,000 vegetation plots from the Harmonised Australian Vegetation plot database overlaid across Australias vegetation classification scheme (the National Vegetation Information System), and we extracted traits from AusTraits, the most comprehensive regional trait database. C_LIO_LIJust 113 plant species (<1% of species found in the region) or the combined species of 16 genera make up 50% of the entire vegetation; approximately 10% of species or the combined species from 10% of the genera (1132 species and 140 genera) make up 90% of vegetation cover. Plant trait coverage tended to be higher when expressed as a proportion of vegetation cover than as a proportion of species in the most common woody genera Acacia and Eucalyptus. Gaps in the trait coverage of very common species were obvious, particularly among the grasses of central Australia. Expressing trait coverage weighted by abundance revealed that only a few additional trait measurements of the most common species and genera would be needed to characterise the traits of most of the vegetation in this part of the continent. C_LIO_LISynthesis: Our results show that a small fraction of species dominates most of the continent. This means that strategic sampling of a few common yet unsampled species could dramatically boost trait coverage and help address the Raunkiaeran shortfall of traits. Targeting these species would substantially improve ecosystem flux estimates and understanding of successful plant strategies at continental scales, with major benefits for vegetation modelling. C_LI

ecology↗

A-Islands: A plant dataset for biodiversity research and species monitoring on Australian islands

Australias coastline is fringed by more than 8,000 continental islands. These islands feature a diverse array of landforms, rock and soil types and geological origins. Some of these islands are among the least invaded, most pristine habitats in Australia and support high plant diversity. Here, we present a new Australia-wide curated dataset for plant species occurrences on islands. Combining information from 1,349 species lists and floras, A-Islands includes data on >6,500 plant species from 844 islands ranging in size from 18 m2 to 4,400 km2, exhibiting different degrees of isolation from the mainland, and spanning all major Australian climate zones. Of these, 251 islands have been repeatedly sampled up to 11 times making it possible to investigate temporal compositional change. A-Islands is open access and will be continuously updated. Its simple data structure consisting of three comma separated files allows easy integration with other Australian and global plant-occurrence databases and can serve as a repository for island research in Australia. Knowing which species occur on Australia's islands will provide opportunities for future research, including studying changes in biodiversity and species-turnover within and among archipelagos, tests of classical island biogeography theory and as a baseline for ecological monitoring and conservation.

ecology↗

Phylogenetically conservative trait correlation: quantification and interpretation

O_LICorrelation across species between two quantitative traits, or between a trait and a habitat property, can suggest that a trait value is effective in sustaining populations in some contexts but not others. It is widely held that such correlations should be controlled for phylogeny, via phylogenetically independent contrasts PICs or phylogenetic generalised least squares PGLS. C_LIO_LITwo weaknesses of this idea are discussed. First, the phylogenetically conservative share of the correlation ought not to be excluded from consideration as potentially ecologically functional. Second, PGLS does not yield a complete or accurate breakdown of A-B covariation, because it corresponds to a generating model where B predicts variation in A but not the reverse. C_LIO_LIMulti-response mixed models using phylogenetic covariance matrices can quantify conservative trait correlation CTC, a share of covariation between traits A and B that is phylogenetically conservative. Because the evidence is from correlative data, it is not possible to split CTC into causation by phylogenetic history versus causation by continuing reciprocal selection between A and B. Moreover, it is quite likely biologically that the two influences have acted in concert, through phylogenetic niche conservatism. C_LIO_LISynthesis: The CTC concept treats phylogenetic conservatism as a conjoint interpretation alongside ongoing influence of other traits. CTC can be quantified via multi-response phylogenetic mixed models. C_LI

ecology↗

Unifying intra- and inter-specific variation in tropical tree mortality

Tree death is a fundamental process driving population dynamics, nutrient cycling, and evolution within plant communities. While past research has identified factors influencing tree mortality across a variety of scales, these distinct drivers are yet to be integrated within a unified predictive framework. In this study, we use a cross-validated Bayesian framework coupled with classic survival analysis techniques to derive instantaneous mortality functions for 203 tropical rainforest tree species at Barro Colorado Island (BCI) Panama. Specifically, we develop mortality functions that not only integrate individual, species, and temporal effects, but also partition the contributions of growth-dependent and growth-independent effects on the overall instantaneous mortality rate. We show that functions that separate mortality rates into growth-dependent and growth-independent hazards, use stem diameter growth rather than basal-area growth, and attribute the effect of wood density to growth-independent mortality outperform alternative formulations. Moreover, we show that the effect of wood density - a prominent trait known to influence tree mortality - explains only 22% of the total variability observed among species. Lastly, our analysis show that growth-dependent processes are the predominant contributor to rates of tree mortality at BCI. Combined, this study provides a framework for predicting individual-level mortality in highly diverse tropical forests. It also highlights how little we know about the causes of species-level and temporal plot-scale effects needed to effectively predict tree mortality.

ecology↗

Coordinated Shifts In Allocation Among Reproductive Tissues Across 14 Coexisting Plant Species

Plant species differ in the amounts of energy allocated to different reproductive tissues, driving differences in their ecology and energy flows within ecosystems. While it is widely agreed that energy allocation is key to reproductive outcomes, few studies have estimated how reproductive effort (RE) is partitioned among different pools, for multiple species in a community. In plants, RE can be partitioned in several meaningful ways: seed versus non-seed tissues; into flowers that form seeds and those that fail to develop; into pre-versus post-pollination tissues, and into successful versus aborted ovules. Evolutionary theory suggests several hypotheses about how these tissues should be coordinated across species. To quantify variation in allocation to different reproductive tissues, we collected detailed RE measurements for a year from 14 perennial species in a recurrent-fire coastal heath community in eastern Australia. Overall we found that total accessory costs - the proportion of RE not directly invested in provisioning the seed - were very large, varying from 95.8% to 99.8% across the study species. These results suggest that studies using seed or fruit production as measures of RE may underestimate it by 10-to 500-fold. We propose a suitable alternative that well-approximates true RE. When comparing species, we found strong support for three evolutionary trade-offs that are predicted to arise when a given energy pool is divided into different tissue masses and counts across species: 1) between successful pollen-attraction costs and mature ovule count, 2) between total reproductive costs and seed count, and 3) between seedset and relative investment in pollen-attraction costs. As a result of these trade-offs, species were also predicted to show coordinated shifts in the amounts invested in floral construction, in seedset and seed size. These shifts in investment were indeed observed, with the amount allocated to discarded tissues increasing with seed size and the amount allocated to pollen-attraction decreasing with seed size. It is already well-established that the seed size axis aligns with the colonization-competition life history spectrum; here we show that relative construction costs of pollen-attraction versus provisioning tissues and seedset are also part of this trajectory, expanding our understanding of the relatives sizes of floral and fruiting structures observed across angiosperms.

ecology↗