bioRxiv Science⌕ Search

Biology subjects

Vigouroux, R.

Publications and source records attributed to Vigouroux, R..

3 recordsLinked to original sources

Variable performances of commercial eDNA inventories challenge their use for surveying stream fish communities

1. Environmental DNA (eDNA) metabarcoding of water samples is increasingly used to detect fish species in streams. Several studies have concluded that it can outperform traditional inventory methods and recommend using it at large scales for fish-based ecological assessments. However, there is no standard protocol that can guarantee sufficient detection rates and repeatability, despite companies offering an extensive range of analyses. 2. We compared eDNA metabarcoding performed by four companies. Following their guidelines, samples were collected in a small tropical stream in the Maroni River (French Guiana) that hosts a species-rich fish community. We compared their inventories to each other and to a list of species captured during an extensive fish inventory performed immediately after sampling eDNA, as well as to current data on the species distributions. 3. The number of species detected by eDNA metabarcoding ranged from 5 to 48 among the companies, but these inventories contained many inaccuracies. All companies combined, 63 species were detected, of which 10 (16%) had never been reported in the Maroni River. The extensive inventory identified 50 species in the local fish community, of which 16-46 were not detected by eDNA metabarcoding (i.e. false negative detection rate of 32%-92% among the companies). 4. Reanalysis of raw sequencing data decreased differences among companies greatly, highlighting the importance of using a comprehensive and accurate DNA barcode database to assign species. Dissimilarity indices, calculated to compare the local fish community (based on presence/absence or fish catches) to eDNA detection, revealed large differences regardless of the company. 5. Summary and applications. The large percentage of species not detected by eDNA metabarcoding of water samples could strongly bias fish-diversity inventories in streams that host species-rich communities. This issue is not well documented in the literature, and we recommend that similar studies in the future focus on other stream contexts. The large differences between commercial eDNA inventories and the local fish community challenge the use of eDNA metabarcoding for fish-based ecological assessments of streams. The variable performance of eDNA companies indicates the need for a standard protocol and access to a comprehensive DNA database before beginning large-scale eDNA programmes. Highlights- eDNA metabarcoding of water samples is widely used to detect species in streams - Detection performances of 4 private companies were compared to an exhaustive fish inventory - The number of undetected species varies from 32 to 92% depending on the company - Such discrepancies challenge the use of eDNA for fish-based ecological assessments

ecology↗

Glycogen Synthase Kinase 3 regulates the genesis of the rare displaced ganglion cell retinal subtype

Glycogen Synthase Kinase 3 (GSK) proteins (GSK3 and GSK3{beta}) are key mediators of signaling pathways, with crucial roles in coordinating fundamental biological processes during neural development. Here we show that the complete loss of GSK3 signaling in mouse retinal progenitors leads to microphthalmia with broad morphological defects. Both proliferation of retinal progenitors and neuronal differentiation are impaired and result in enhanced cell death. A single wild-type allele of either Gsk3 or Gsk3{beta} is able to rescue these phenotypes. In this genetic context, all cell types are present with a functional retina. However, we unexpectedly detect a large number of cells in the inner nuclear layer expressing retinal ganglion cell (RGC)-specific markers (called displaced RGCs, dRGCs) when at least one allele of Gsk3 is expressed. Excess dRGCs lead to increased number of axons projecting into the ipsilateral medial terminal nucleus, an area of the brain belonging to the non-image-forming visual circuit and poorly targeted by RGCs in wild-type retina. Transcriptome analysis and optomotor response assay suggest that at least a subset of dRGCs in Gsk3 mutant mice are direction-selective RGCs. Our study thus uncovers a unique role of GSK3 in controlling the genesis of dRGCs, a rare and poorly characterized retinal cell type.

neuroscience↗

Characterizing the spatial signal of environmental DNA in river systems using a community ecology approach

Environmental DNA (eDNA) is gaining a growing popularity among scientists but its applicability to biodiversity research and management remains limited in river systems by the lack of knowledge about the spatial extent of the downstream transport of eDNA. Here, we assessed the ability of eDNA inventories to retrieve spatial patterns of fish assemblages along two large and species rich Neotropical rivers. We first examined overall community variation with distance through the distance decay of similarity and compared this pattern to capture-based samples. We then considered previous knowledge on individual species distributions, and compared it to the eDNA inventories for a set of 53 species. eDNA collected from 28 sites in the Maroni and 25 sites in the Oyapock rivers permitted to retrieve a decline of species similarity with distance between sites. The distance decay of similarity derived from eDNA was similar, and even more pronounced, than that obtained with capture-based methods (gil-nets). In addition, the species upstream-downstream distribution range derived from eDNA matched to the known distribution of most species. Our results demonstrate that environmental DNA does not represent an integrative measure of biodiversity across the whole upstream river basin but provide a relevant picture of local fish assemblages. Importantly, the spatial signal gathered from eDNA was therefore comparable to that gathered with local capture based methods, which describes fish fauna over a few hundred metres.

ecology↗