Fundamental-realized niche contrasts shape multi-scale species coexistence
Ecological theory states that the geographic ranges and coexistence of species are determined by fundamental and realized niches -- the sets of environments where a species intrinsic population growth rate is positive in the absence and presence of competitors, respectively. Yet large-scale tests of niche theory have been hampered by the challenge to obtain sufficient data on demography and competition. Here, we quantify fundamental and realized niches by combining data on variation in fundamental demographic rates, community composition and the abiotic environment across the global geographic ranges of 29 shrub species from the South African Fynbos biome (a global biodiversity hotspot). Estimated pairwise competition coefficients and fundamental-realized niche contrasts reveal multi-scale mechanisms of species coexistence. At small scales, species generally exert stronger competition on themselves than on other species. At biogeographical scales, more competitive species have narrower fundamental niches but are not significantly better dispersed, which provides evidence for a generalist-specialist trade-off rather than a competition-colonization trade-off. Under both present and future climates, interspecific competition more strongly limits the realized niches and geographic ranges of generalist species. The large-scale application of niche theory thus identifies key forces shaping biodiversity and indicates that generalist species may be more strongly impacted by climate change than previously thought.